@CrazyPaco You have raised some good points, but how do you explain Boston College making a super regional 2 years ago? Their outfield was used as parking for football games. I know they have since built a new stadium--opening up next week, but I think they are a fair comp for our program.
I understand the finance aspect, but there is no excuse for not even sliding in the ACC tournament at least once. My biggest bone to pick is how poorly we recruit in the region.
If you want an example of poor recruiting go look at the class that should've been true seniors this year... Couple of draft picks come to mind (Leblanc/Mattson), but I know of at least 6 kids who transferred/quit--our attrition numbers from a recruiting standpoint are embarrassing.. Most these cases were not talent related either as most have gone on to play with other programs and have success..
All in all you are 100% right about giving to the program. At the end of the day my stance comes from wanting the athletes to have a great experience at Pitt and they not getting that--but instead they get a coach who does not show up to practice or give a crap about anything but his "legacy".