ADVERTISEMENT

Best starter at Pitt that was under utilized?

cbpitt2

Freshman
Sep 12, 2011
1,334
675
113
I'm trying to rack my old brains but can't come up with anyone better than Bartholomew.

Ollison in 2017? Others?
 
  • Like
Reactions: imrealangry
I'm trying to rack my old brains but can't come up with anyone better than Bartholomew.

Ollison in 2017? Others?
I’ve been going to Pitt games since the Hart years and I’ve seen many under utilized players, but none like Bart.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Snyder412
Kris Wilson in the early 2000s and (unironically) Mike Shanahan are two guys who come to mind that haven’t mentioned yet. Also like the Ollison mention, but I agree that Gavin B appears to be the biggest one.
 
thinking we should have done something with Dinkins in the late 90s other than 3rd string qb. obviously a good athlete..

Didnt the Decicco guy actually become a linebacker in the nfl?
 
Kris Wilson in the early 2000s and (unironically) Mike Shanahan are two guys who come to mind that haven’t mentioned yet. Also like the Ollison mention, but I agree that Gavin B appears to be the biggest one.
Wilson is tough to say because there were so many great WR (including the best one ever) at his time at Pitt and only so many passes to go around to warrant a whole lot of throws to the TE… but he was a good one.

I think Ollison overall got sufficient PT and chances in his time. He and Hall were a good tandem. Seems to fit todays trends with RB, to split their time and not to run the wheels off one of them exclusively.

Shanny is a good call, he was a matchup nightmare but our OCs weren’t clever enough to realize or exploit it. Sounds familiar…
 
  • Like
Reactions: HailToPitt725
he did get 20-ish touches every time he was healthy enough to play. He was heavily used in the passing game and had a lot of receiving touches as well.
No he wasn’t. They used older guys ahead of him earlier in his career when he was better and then at the end Majors held him out figuring it would force his hand to return. It didn’t work.
 
Kevan Barlow
See I can’t say guys like him or Kris Wilson or Ollison etc because they did get fairly significant time and touches. They didn’t get the wheels totally run off of them but they got the ball often.

I interpreted this to be guys like Bart who clearly have talent yet got next to ZERO plays or touches
 
  • Like
Reactions: HailToPitt725
thinking we should have done something with Dinkins in the late 90s other than 3rd string qb. obviously a good athlete..

Didnt the Decicco guy actually become a linebacker in the nfl?
Dinkins was only a 3rd string QB his freshman year. He finished his last 2.5 years as a safety. He lost his starting job to Ramon Walker when he was a senior.
Kevan Barlow
this is probably it. However, you have to be able to put yourself in a position to be utilized if you want to produce. Much of his career he was his own worst enemy. His senior year, he should've finished every game with a minimum of 20-25 touches a game.
 
Dinkins was only a 3rd string QB his freshman year. He finished his last 2.5 years as a safety. He lost his starting job to Ramon Walker when he was a senior.
hmmm, thanks Steel, i wasnt aware of this. I remember him being 3rd string QB but i dont remember 2 1/2 years of him at safety..

So i stand corrected..
 
hmmm, thanks Steel, i wasnt aware of this. I remember him being 3rd string QB but i dont remember 2 1/2 years of him at safety..

So i stand corrected..
I recall Dinkins making a pretty impressive interception in the end zone to save a loss against someone like Houston (?). I recall it salvaging a win that we eventually needed to go .500 in that magical 😆 1997 season. It was like an attempted throw away but he made this Fitz like catch to leap up and manage to drag his toes inbounds to snare it. At the time we were thinking “dang he’d be better as a receiver” because he was, well, a less than enthusiastic tackler. And of course he eventually played TE in the NFL.
 
I'm trying to rack my old brains but can't come up with anyone better than Bartholomew.

Ollison in 2017? Others?
Easy.

Larry Fitzgerald. 1 guy, 2 guys, 3 guys…doesn’t matter. Larry couldn’t be defended. Whatever the number of his targets were his sophomore year, they should have been doubled.

Continental Tire Bowl-1st and goal from the one…he should have been targeted on every down. Of course he wasn’t even on the field then…but that’s also the point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pitt_87
Easy.

Larry Fitzgerald. 1 guy, 2 guys, 3 guys…doesn’t matter. Larry couldn’t be defended. Whatever the number of his targets were his sophomore year, they should have been doubled.

Continental Tire Bowl-1st and goal from the one…he should have been targeted on every down. Of course he wasn’t even on the field then…but that’s also the point.
Normally I’d not be able to agree, as Fitz got a lot of looks (per my criteria above)…but he was not a normal player, either.

So in his case, and probably Shady as well, as much as they got the call, I definitely couldn’t argue with the idea they should have gotten even more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fk_Pitt
Bart's misuse is criminal. He is not your typical in-line TE. He's much more effective as a flexed-out pass catcher, in a role similar to what Kyle Pitts had at Florida. They're trying to fit a square peg in a round hole with him on offense. Letting him be good at what he's good at shouldn't be that hard!
 
  • Like
Reactions: jivecat
Bart's misuse is criminal. He is not your typical in-line TE. He's much more effective as a flexed-out pass catcher, in a role similar to what Kyle Pitts had at Florida. They're trying to fit a square peg in a round hole with him on offense. Letting him be good at what he's good at shouldn't be that hard!
The issue seems to be that Duz favorite kind of tight end is a Tackle Eligible
 
Billy west getting benched for prioritizing engineering degree over mid week practice is a good one.

Had a huge season on 1996 and won big East offensive player of the year and backed up Dwayne schulters a year later.
Beat me too it. Pitt wasted a lot of great players during Majors 2
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT