Listed below are Pitt Florida recruit numbers and names to qualify or disqualify the Florida analysts claims. Some were impressed with the article because he spoke highly of Pitt's recruits. Personally, I think he was appeasing his audience to a degree and blowing hot air. Quote: " A 3-star in Florida could be a 4-star elsewhere". Look at the roster below and put that to test. Taking his theory and re-applying it, one can assume, a Florida 2-star could be a 3-star elsewhere.
There's no question concerning Florida high school football. However, lots of blanket statements are made about a lot of things and then taken for truth. The analyst kind of cherry picked to make his point. However, I'm not sure Pitt is a good example to affirm it. Perhaps some other schools, but I'm not sure Pitt's history with Florida players confirms his overall thoughts. Maybe, but I'm not so sure.
One could say 3 star recruits Darrel Revis Aaron Donald, Jason Pinkston, Mick Williams, Scott McKillop, James Conner and 2 star recruits Devin Street, Tommie Campbell and host of others would have been rated higher had they lived in Florida. Had Tyler Boyd attended Miami Central, Pitt would have probably recruited against the entire SEC plus Miami, Florida State and Clemson. But, he attended Clairton PA High School, not Miami Central.
Bottom line, it goes both ways. Within a 10 year period, 35 recruits came from Florida. That's around 15% or nearly a class and a half of players to draw some conclusions from. Mixed bag to say the least. For every Gus Mastakas and Rashard Duncan there's a Roderick Ryles or Jared Martin. Same could be said for Pennsylvania, Ohio, NJ, etc. One thing I do agree with him on however, is the impact of year around football. While, not year around, the emergence of 7-on-7 tournaments and competition may have a role in western PA's seeing an uptick in defensive backs. Tournaments and practices in spring and summer has seemingly paid some dividends.
Florida Recruits: 2002 - 2011
Conredge Collins RB Miami, FL
Vernon Smith LB Fort Lauderdale, FL
4 stars - 2
Reggie Carter DB Naples, FL
Charles Sallet LB Seffner, FL
H.B. Blades LB Plantation, FL
Jameel Brady DB Miami, FL
Greg Lee WR Tampa, FL
Clint Session LB Pompano Beach, FL
Marcel Pestano WR Lehigh Acres, FL
Jerald Robinson OL Fort Pierce, FL
Cedric McGee WR Plantation, FL
Dexter Davidson QB Coconut Creek, FL
Ricky Gary DB Pahokee, FL
Jared Martin DT Davie, FL
Tamarcus Porter ATH Pahokee, FL
Jabaal Sheard DE Hollywood, FL
Greg Williams RB Naples, FL
Jason Douglas RB Weston, FL
Shane Gordon LB Weston, FL
Roderick Ryles DB Orlando, FL
LaQuentin Smith LB Orlando, FL
3 stars - 17
Zack Schlundt OL Punta Gorda, FL
AJ Schneider RB Tampa, FL
Kennard Cox ATH Miami, FL
Joe Clermond LB Tampa, FL
Nick Williams DE Plantation, FL
Darrell Strong ATH Plantation, FL
Jerald Robinson OL Fort Pierce, FL
Marcel Pestano WR Lehigh Acres, FL
Kelvin Chandler WR Ft. Lauderdale, FL
Gus Mustakas DE Hollywood, FL
Rashad Duncan DT Belle Glade, FL
Tommie Duhart TE Belle Glade, FL
Steve Dell LB Lantana, FL
Greg Romeus DE Coral Springs, FL
Joe Trebitz LB Boca Raton, FL
Ronald Jones WR Fort Meade, FL
2 stars - 16
Combined Total - 35