I assume by "value" we're really just talking about TV viewership and ratings. if that's the case, this list looks pretty similar to others I've seen over the past several years. It's basically a regurgitation of the Nielsen ratings. The only ACC teams that get much viewership outside the ACCN are Clemson and FSU. Seems pretty logical that, excepting ND, the bigger state schools that are in areas with bigger TV markets would have more viewership/higher ratings since they have more alums living in major cities across the country, which means more viewers. Take ASU for instance, which a poster above used as an example of the flaws in this list. ASU is in the Phoenix TV market and there are over 325,000 ASU alumni in the Phoemix metro alone, over 600,000 around the country. Same kinds of numbers for Indiana (almost 800k living alums, over 400k in Indiana alone), Michigan State, etc. Alums watch their schools' games regardless of how bad their teams are.
Agree that not all of these placements make sense, especially the WVU one. Here are the Nielsen's:
Power 5 Breakdown (per game)
Here are the average Nielsen viewers for the Power 5 schools that averaged at least a million viewers per game. (Not all teams played the same number of games on Nielsen-rated networks.)
ACC: Florida State 4.16, Clemson 2.90, Miami 2.65, Duke 2.63, Louisville 2.37, North Carolina 1.93, Georgia Tech 1.83, Boston College 1.48, Pitt 1.37, Syracuse 1.20, NC State 1.13, Virginia Tech 1.02. Others: Virginia, Wake Forest.
Big 12: Texas 4.26, Oklahoma 2.61, Oklahoma State 1.96, TCU 1.70, Kansas 1.48, West Virginia 1.45, Iowa State 1.37, BYU 1.31, Kansas State 1.30, Texas Tech 1.30, Baylor 1.09. Others: Cincinnati, Houston, UCF.
Big Ten: Ohio State 6.05, Michigan 5.61, Penn State 3.66, Iowa 2.68, Nebraska 2.63, Michigan State 1.65, Wisconsin 1.61, Maryland 1.55, Minnesota 1.44, Indiana 1.26, Rutgers 1.14. Others: Illinois, Northwestern, Purdue.
Pac-12: Colorado 6.00, Oregon 4.43, Washington 4.14, USC 3.77, Utah 2.61, Oregon State 2.44, Washington State 2.15, UCLA 1.67, Stanford 1.64, Arizona 1.30, Arizona State 1.20, Cal 1.08.
SEC: Alabama 7.12, Georgia 5.90, Tennessee 4.57, LSU 3.79, Auburn 3.55, Missouri 3.25, Florida 3.17, Ole Miss 2.93, Texas A&M 2.74, South Carolina 2.69, Vanderbilt 2.46, Kentucky 2.07, Mississippi State 2.01, Arkansas 1.93.
Independent: Notre Dame 4.15.