ADVERTISEMENT

Knight is going to TCU w/ Dixon...

goodinsider

Freshman
Gold Member
Feb 2, 2005
1,513
738
113
75062
they're awaiting to see if he can secure Pitt job first... JD has time to set staff... Likely getting most done at Final 4 in Houston... Pitt situation should be clear by then... Still a possibility that BK stays at top Ass't w/ raise depending on whom gets job over him... However this works out... Dixon won't leave Brandon hanging
 
they're awaiting to see if he can secure Pitt job first... JD has time to set staff... Likely getting most done at Final 4 in Houston... Pitt situation should be clear by then... Still a possibility that BK stays at top Ass't w/ raise depending on whom gets job over him... However this works out... Dixon won't leave Brandon hanging
In all honesty, BK needs to spread his wings under another HC or else get his own HC gig at a smaller school.
 
In all honesty, BK needs to spread his wings under another HC or else get his own HC gig at a smaller school.
Agreed. It would be a really bad choice by JD as well.. He needs guys who have ties to the regions he will be recruiting.
 
Agreed. It would be a really bad choice by JD as well.. He needs guys who have ties to the regions he will be recruiting.
Don't be shocked if Jones grad transfers with them... I'm not saying this for sure, but rather a guy feeling... Jones allows JD to implement his style and plays more readily helping them to a winning season... Now if a new hire happens with some real promise perhaps he stays, but I got a feeling he is loyal to Dixon... Just keep an eye on that one... I understand he in fact is only one with eligibility that can graduate to move
 
  • Like
Reactions: freddietee511
In all honesty, BK needs to spread his wings under another HC or else get his own HC gig at a smaller school.
Agreed.
BK can be successful. But he should go elsewhere and with new blood.
Ask Tom Bradley how sticking with one system works out when you are trying to get your own gig.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cavalier Panther
Agreed.
BK can be successful. But he should go elsewhere and with new blood.
Ask Tom Bradley how sticking with one system works out when you are trying to get your own gig.
That's a good analogy... Though Knight still early in career, could still benefit with a few more years then a lower level HC job... But I see your point... Be interesting to see
 
Don't be shocked if Jones grad transfers with them... I'm not saying this for sure, but rather a guy feeling... Jones allows JD to implement his style and plays more readily helping them to a winning season... Now if a new hire happens with some real promise perhaps he stays, but I got a feeling he is loyal to Dixon... Just keep an eye on that one... I understand he in fact is only one with eligibility that can graduate to move

Yea I think you're right about Jones being able to grad transfer.

I would guess if Artis and Young don't like what they see they could bail and try a foreign league as that seems likely to be their only pro options. However for all I know they both may desire to get their degrees.
 
The coaching business doesn't seem to be too different than most others. Diversity of experience is a very important thing. Different places, different "management" styles, different ways of dealing with problems allow you to become a good leader and manager at your later stops.

Obviously, there are guys like Greg Gard out there who are lifelong assistants that finally get their shot - and Gard may turn out to be a great fit for Wisconsin for quite some time.

But for me in my business life, I've always been partial to people who haven't been afraid to buy in to themselves and move around while learning from others. It's a good thing to experience different places and challenges and styles of management.

I think for Brandin, if Jamie does ask him to come to Texas well, at least it's a good and pretty comfy gig for a pretty good while. But if his hope is to become a DI head coach some day - it's probably time for him to spread his wings, and to bet on and believe in himself. It might mean a step down in the short term, but the benefits could be great.
 
they're awaiting to see if he can secure Pitt job first... JD has time to set staff... Likely getting most done at Final 4 in Houston... Pitt situation should be clear by then... Still a possibility that BK stays at top Ass't w/ raise depending on whom gets job over him... However this works out... Dixon won't leave Brandon hanging
That would be a terrible decision by both, IMO, but not surprising based on history.
 
Knight saw on the Pantherlair that it would be an indictment on his abilities if he didn't go. Can't blame the guy, this is the place for intellectuals and movers and shakers.
 
Don't be shocked if Jones grad transfers with them... I'm not saying this for sure, but rather a guy feeling... Jones allows JD to implement his style and plays more readily helping them to a winning season... Now if a new hire happens with some real promise perhaps he stays, but I got a feeling he is loyal to Dixon... Just keep an eye on that one... I understand he in fact is only one with eligibility that can graduate to move

What is a "guy feeling?" Anything like Women's intuition? LOL

Still ... that's not a crazy suggestion at all. (as a 5th year senior)
 
Agree with what most of you have said.

Brandon Knight needs to get a HC job somewhere and not stay under Dixon. Or possibly even take a lateral move somewhere else. If his "hands" were truly tied in recruiting as it has been stated, then he needs to prove he can recruit and coach. No other way to do that then get from under Dixon.

Also, Pitt needs to play a role in Brandon's development and work hard NOT to burn that bridge. Brandon could be the next best thing, but I don't want Pitt to be the school to experiment on that. But I would like to leave the door open for future possibilities.

I can't wait until the search is over.
 
Agree with what most of you have said.

Brandon Knight needs to get a HC job somewhere and not stay under Dixon. Or possibly even take a lateral move somewhere else. If his "hands" were truly tied in recruiting as it has been stated, then he needs to prove he can recruit and coach. No other way to do that then get from under Dixon.

Also, Pitt needs to play a role in Brandon's development and work hard NOT to burn that bridge. Brandon could be the next best thing, but I don't want Pitt to be the school to experiment on that. But I would like to leave the door open for future possibilities.

I can't wait until the search is over.
In another thread, I made a comparison between BK and Paul Chryst: just as Chryst came to Pitt to be our HC, and then used Pitt as his stepping-stone to the Wisky job, Knight should go elsewhere to get his head coaching experience. Once he proves himself as a good HC at a lower level, then he'll be a better HC candidate the next time that the Pitt job opens-up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PantherO
they're awaiting to see if he can secure Pitt job first... JD has time to set staff... Likely getting most done at Final 4 in Houston... Pitt situation should be clear by then... Still a possibility that BK stays at top Ass't w/ raise depending on whom gets job over him... However this works out... Dixon won't leave Brandon hanging
do footnotes or the phrases "I believe" or "I think" exist anymore?
 
In all honesty, BK needs to spread his wings under another HC or else get his own HC gig at a smaller school.
If Brandon wants to be a HC then he should move on and put his hat in the ring of any vacant HC positions, and that's if he wants to coach his own team!
 
The new coach will be in a position to bring in his own staff. If BK is part of the new staff it will be due to the new coach saying he will. This is an opportunity to move the BB program up and Barnes and Gallagher see this as that opportunity.
 
It is, but many, like pirahna take their opinion as fact.
Unless something comes from Chris or Matt, I automatically assume that it's someone's opinion. And even Matt & Chris have opinions, too, but they're extra-careful to label them as such.

A lot of times, I'll start a post with "IMHO" - which I feel is a silly redundancy. Yet I do it anyway, so that if what I said doesn't happen, some nitpicker doesn't come back at me with a "Boy, were you wrong!" comment.
 
they're awaiting to see if he can secure Pitt job first... JD has time to set staff... Likely getting most done at Final 4 in Houston... Pitt situation should be clear by then... Still a possibility that BK stays at top Ass't w/ raise depending on whom gets job over him... However this works out... Dixon won't leave Brandon hanging

Sounds familiar. Remember when Howland left for UCLA? He left a seat open on his bench for Jamie in case he didn't get the Pitt job.
 
Pitt fans have done enough worrying about their coaches returning to their alma maters. I'd like the shoe to be on the other foot about 10 or 12 years from now, with some school worrying about Knight returning to Pitt.
 
Don't be shocked if Jones grad transfers with them... I'm not saying this for sure, but rather a guy feeling... Jones allows JD to implement his style and plays more readily helping them to a winning season... Now if a new hire happens with some real promise perhaps he stays, but I got a feeling he is loyal to Dixon... Just keep an eye on that one... I understand he in fact is only one with eligibility that can graduate to move
If Pitt would retain Knight even as an asst., I don't think there's any way he goes to TCU for the same job. I think Jones transferring is much more realistic.
 
If Pitt would retain Knight even as an asst., I don't think there's any way he goes to TCU for the same job. I think Jones transferring is much more realistic.

Depending on who the new coach is he might not want Knight. Knight's been here for a long time. Having someone like that around could cause problems. Not saying Knight would intentionally be subversive or sneaky but I would think a new coach would want his own guys.
 
Conversely, if a new coach comes in and keeps BK, it might prevent some departures.

Agreed.

I just think this could be a very tricky dynamic. That's not to say it couldn't work but if it were me I'd be leery.

I've seen a few different CEOs replaced at places I've worked. More often than not when the internal candidate(s) didn't get it they moved on.
 
Point well taken, but as it's an internet message board, 99% of what's written here is opinion - doncha think? ;)
Not when I see "Knight going to TCU w/Dixon" as the title of the post. Oddly enough I think it to be news I have yet to hear. Simple question mark at the end would suffice and save me ten seconds of my day reading more unfounded conjecture.......
 
they're awaiting to see if he can secure Pitt job first... JD has time to set staff... Likely getting most done at Final 4 in Houston... Pitt situation should be clear by then... Still a possibility that BK stays at top Ass't w/ raise depending on whom gets job over him... However this works out... Dixon won't leave Brandon hanging

LOLOL Did Deano tell you that?
 
in 8 years what p5 school has asked Pitt's permission to interview Knight for their HC job?
 
Depending on who the new coach is he might not want Knight. Knight's been here for a long time. Having someone like that around could cause problems. Not saying Knight would intentionally be subversive or sneaky but I would think a new coach would want his own guys.
Definitely. I think I would want a coach who will keep Knight though. Firing Knight might be enough to eliminate a coach from contention. Basically you have to be one of the best recruiters in the country and back it up if you let Knight go. If Knight's gone we will have no recruiting class to speak of this upcoming season.
 
Definitely. I think I would want a coach who will keep Knight though. Firing Knight might be enough to eliminate a coach from contention. Basically you have to be one of the best recruiters in the country and back it up if you let Knight go. If Knight's gone we will have no recruiting class to speak of this upcoming season.

The best coach identified and willing to accept should be hired. If he and Knight can come to terms, great. If not so be it. The guy should have the ability to hire his own staff.

And passing on #1 choice and hiring #2 because he agrees to keep Knight wouldn't be a good idea IMO.
 
The best coach identified and willing to accept should be hired. If he and Knight can come to terms, great. If not so be it. The guy should have the ability to hire his own staff.

And passing on #1 choice and hiring #2 because he agrees to keep Knight wouldn't be a good idea IMO.
Oh I agree, but only if the candidate really is a good choice. I just don't want them to settle for a decent hire that fires Knight because we will basically being throwing this year's class away. Now if they go out and get someone who they really feel is a big hire that will bring this program back to where it was and he doesn't retain Knight, so be it. But hiring say the guy from GW and getting rid of Knight, not a good idea IMO. I'm personally holding out hope we get Enfield. I would be totally fine with Enfield and no Knight.
 
Oh I agree, but only if the candidate really is a good choice. I just don't want them to settle for a decent hire that fires Knight because we will basically being throwing this year's class away. Now if they go out and get someone who they really feel is a big hire that will bring this program back to where it was and he doesn't retain Knight, so be it. But hiring say the guy from GW and getting rid of Knight, not a good idea IMO. I'm personally holding out hope we get Enfield. I would be totally fine with Enfield and no Knight.
You mean the 72nd rated recruiting class? I say they can stay or leave and if you want to leave don't let the door hit you where the lord splityou!
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT