I am not sure who to root for, quite frankly?
However, I don't really disagree with Mike Leach here. There do seem to be a ridiculous amount of bandwagon fans with the Cubs.
I had no idea that it was a socioeconomic thing until I was in Chicago a little while ago. I had a taxi driver kind of alert me to the fact.
He basically said that the real baseball fans in Chicago are White Sox fans and that it was his opinion that most Cubs fans were definitely Johnny-come-lately types who liked the atmosphere at Wrigley Field and the uniforms more than the actual team.
His words, not mine.
Anyway, if I didn't have so many friends from Cleveland, I would probably be rooting for the Tribe. However, the way they reacted to the Cavaliers' championship gives me pause. Maybe the world is better when Cleveland isn't winning?
I still think I'm going to read for Cleveland but I'm going to do so with gnashed teeth.
As someone who's lived in Chicago for the last 12 years, I feel like I have to weigh in on your cab driver's opinion. He's sort of right...
The Cubs absolutely have an enormous and loyal fan base rivaling any team in baseball save for maybe the Yankess. The city may explode if they win the world series because they are absolutely the #1 team in the town regardless of how many restaurants Mike Ditka opens.
However, the true blue Cubs fans, in my experience, don't live in Wrigleyville, Lincoln Park, Gold Coast, Wicker Park, etc - the trendy, upscale neighborhoods in the city. The real, life-long Cubs fans live in the more blue collar neighborhoods in the North and West, and a ton live in the suburbs (where I moved two years ago). These people eat, breath, sleep Cubs and have their entire life. I respect them, but I find many of the Cubs fans who are actually at the games obnoxious.
What bugs me about Cubs fans and is the #1 reason why I could never get behind them no matter how long I live here (besides my undying loyalty to all things Pittsburgh), is what Dr's Cabbie described.
Every Big Ten/MAC/Big 12 frat boy graduate who moves to Chicago after college likes the Cubs because it's the thing to do. A social event. Go to a regular season game on a Friday afternoon and sit in the bleachers. 70% of the people aren't even watching the games. They are just drinking and having fun. I've done this countless times, mainly because it is indeed a lot of fun - but I never root for the Cubs when I do it. That's what bugs me. These people don't care about the game, they care about a good time. They might have been Reds fans, Tigers fans, Twins fans - but because they live in Wrigleyville when they are 25 they now like the Cubs. It's a similar phenomenon to what happens in Boston where the New England college grads all move to Boston and like the Red Sox.
I respect fans who are loyal no matter where they live and don't change loyalties over the years. White Sox fans are loyal, there just aren't many of them compared to Cubs "fans" especially if you're someplace that isn't south of the city. Make no mistake the Cubs have a massive fan base. They're just not always the people you meet in and around the stadium. I'm sure some of the yuppie fans do grow to really love the Cubs, but they buy that first jersey and start drinking Old Style because it's a fun way to spend a summer day, not because they grew up loving the Cubs.
Despite my ties to the city and my countless true Cubs fans, I could not be rooting any harder for Cleveland. Weird to type "rooting for Cleveland."