Good god look who your comparing Pitt to , two of the finest universities that exist ( ND and Stanford ) a basketball elite( Ind) and an excellent school in a weathly section of Philly with a local recruiting base any coach would die for. I think Pitt tried to recruit with the big boys over estimating the draw of the ACC ,they lost all those battles and the kids next up realized they weren't the prime targets and went elsewhere were they were the prime targets.
Pitts a fine university ,they play in a fine faculty ,they play in the strongest conference ,they do have a good coach,but so do a lot of other schools . Pitt has no local recruiting base, kids from the east don't seem to gravitate to the ACC schools ,kids from the Midwest go to the Big 10, southern kids stay south. Elite kids go to elite programs. Quite a pickle huh!
I went to the game at Miami what a campus . Oakland ( 5th and Forbes concrete ) vs Coral Gables ( green grass ,palm trees , outdoor pools ,restaurants and girls ), 10 degrees vs 70 . I can't see how Pitt could compete with them let alone Duke ,UNC ,and Louisville for players.
If you wish to believe that everything is equal in college athletics who am I to tell you otherwise. They need to get back to recruiting Pitt style basketball players and with next years additions I think they're on the way.