Well again, this shows some of the folly of rankings. Was Cosentino a 4 star and FSU recruited him over a bunch of P5 power programs? Or was Cosentino recruited by FSU and having the legacy of Western PA QB's and his size, these recruiting experts figured he must be good so they slapped 4 stars to him.
Since this is recent history, I would definitely think it is the latter. I think this is a perfect example of stars not mattering, because the only thing I really remember this kid being lauded for his as a punter.