I posted this on the pay board to someone defending Capel, but most of it is relevant here.
It's not "critical thinking" that you are doing, it is "creative thinking". Look, being positive and an optimist is one thing. But sports, the beauty of it, unlike politics is it is results oriented. One game? One season? Sure. There are always circumstances, reasons, outliers, aberrations that can occur both negative AND positively that makes it hard to come to any conclusion.
4 seasons? Nah. That's a book. It has been written. The results?
14-19
16-17
10-12
11-21
You can say "hey, his first year in the ACC they only won 3 conference games. This year they won 6". Great. They also won 6 games in year's 2 and 3. And this year, the conference is as down as it ever has been. We didn't have to play Duke twice. We didn't have to play Carolina twice.
Recruiting? 1 High School kid last year. Zero this year. So looking ahead, the future? OK. We completely lucked out with Mo Gueye. Burton is a decent player, but he is not anyone that is going to elevate us.
Results. Critical thinking. I see a coaching staff that has never changed. I don't see player development? Damned if I can figure out an offensive philosophy. Horton got hot for what, 2 games, maybe 3, then other teams guarded him and we realized why he was at Delaware because when ACC level kids guard him, he can't get open. Of course, it would be nice for the HC to recognize this and you know, run some sets, some picks, cuts, something to get open.
The team has no coach on the floor (PG) which matches no coach on the bench. Guys are what they are. Champ, Toney, X, were good when they got here. Hugley when he finally played showed he is good. But all other young recruits don't develop and or leave.
Results. I don't hate Jeff Capel. I now hate the hiring of Jeff Capel and the extension Heather gave him is every bit the disaster as was the hiring of Kevin Stallings. Every bit.
And Capel still doesn't get or accept blame. Is he trying to get fired? He is almost defiant. How is he going to recruit anyone? Who is going to come here and play for him? What, use "NIL" money, well if the kid is good enough so will others. We are dead. The program is dead as long as Capel is the coach we are dead. Done. There is nothing we can do. Nothing. At least realistically. This lineup adding a Brown grad and say a transfer from I dunno, Detroit Mercy or Richmond, aren't going to turn this into an NIT team, especially with likely Femi leaving.