ADVERTISEMENT

Offer Chip Kelly the OC job

HailtoPitt

Board of Trustee
Jun 18, 2001
29,793
11,660
113
Before some of you feel the need to attack, yes I understand that the OC job at Pitt is a big step down, but getting fired this late in the game leaves the Pitt OC job as a one of the better positions left open. He will still get paid by Philly and SF so he may not command and outrageous salary.

Now, launch your bombs at me.
 
Before some of you feel the need to attack, yes I understand that the OC job at Pitt is a big step down, but getting fired this late in the game leaves the Pitt OC job as a one of the better positions left open. He will still get paid by Philly and SF so he may not command and outrageous salary.

Now, launch your bombs at me.
No bombs.. I like it.
He's got money..
 
  • Like
Reactions: paulbl99
Chip Kelly would be a great choice for us but he is now an NFL guy and at worst will be an OC in the NFL if not a HC next season
 
Outside possibility - Brian Kelly goes to the pros and Chip takes over at ND.
 
A home run hire like Canada will make you looking for a new OC a year later. It's not necessarily a bad thing. If you want a guy that will be around 3-4 years, you are going to have to find an inexperienced younger guy. Not sure narduzzi wants that, to babysit the OC for a year or two.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Piranha
To me, its not about "the guy". And as many here have said, a successful guy may be gone again in a year, and we do this all over again.
Its about "the system". This year, we had a very successful system, one that was well suited to our players' strengths. I'd like to see that system continued regardless of who the guy is. I don't want our players to have to learn a new offensive scheme in the spring, having to learn the new guy's terminology, etc, and possibly trying to make a system work that they're not really built for.
Continuity is important, and we can have it if the new OC is a flexible guy who doesn't insist on imposing 'his system.'
Tim Salem is the obvious choice to accomplish this. He's been an OC before, so he has experience. I don't know what PN thinks of him as a leader at the OC level or his play calling ability, but if likes him in these regards and hires him, I'll be very happy.
Some of you will of course, criticize the hire as a cheap in-house option, and be disappointed that we didn't get a big name guy...for one year. I won't.
 
In theory, it would be a brilliant hire. In reality, it would be as likely as getting President Obama to be the mayor of Aliquippa.
 
To me, its not about "the guy". And as many here have said, a successful guy may be gone again in a year, and we do this all over again.
Its about "the system". This year, we had a very successful system, one that was well suited to our players' strengths. I'd like to see that system continued regardless of who the guy is. I don't want our players to have to learn a new offensive scheme in the spring, having to learn the new guy's terminology, etc, and possibly trying to make a system work that they're not really built for.
Continuity is important, and we can have it if the new OC is a flexible guy who doesn't insist on imposing 'his system.'
Tim Salem is the obvious choice to accomplish this. He's been an OC before, so he has experience. I don't know what PN thinks of him as a leader at the OC level or his play calling ability, but if likes him in these regards and hires him, I'll be very happy.
Some of you will of course, criticize the hire as a cheap in-house option, and be disappointed that we didn't get a big name guy...for one year. I won't.

I'm in that latter group. Just because TS saw Canada do it does NOT mean that TS can step in and do it. Knowing it is one thing; teaching it, getting the bugs out, making the calls -- is another skill and another matter. One that TS hasn't demonstrated...

Go Pitt
 
He'll be a college HC. He will never see the NFL again because his style doesn't lend itself to week after week of close competition or when the other team has more talent.

Now in college where you can exploit talent differential week after week and then win that one big game because the other team isn't used it? Sure.

But not as an OC. I can see him winding up at a top non-P5 school. Something like a Houston if that would have still been open
 
  • Like
Reactions: Panther Parrothead
He'll be a college HC. He will never see the NFL again because his style doesn't lend itself to week after week of close competition or when the other team has more talent.

Now in college where you can exploit talent differential week after week and then win that one big game because the other team isn't used it? Sure.

But not as an OC. I can see him winding up at a top non-P5 school. Something like a Houston if that would have still been open
If the Nits could, they'd offer Chip Kelly the head coaching position right now. But ironically, the success that Franklin had would never permit it. ;)
 
Salem has been an OC, so he has experience doing all of that. How good he is at doing it is something PN will evaluate, and he'll make his decision. If he doesn't think he's up to it, he won't hire him. If he does, he may. I'll go with his call either way. What I'm saying is that I won't be disappointed if he hires him instead of a current big name OC.
 
The odds of chip Kelly becoming the OC are the same as Sean Miller fan the poster becoming HC of the Pitt basketball team.
 
Before some of you feel the need to attack, yes I understand that the OC job at Pitt is a big step down, but getting fired this late in the game leaves the Pitt OC job as a one of the better positions left open. He will still get paid by Philly and SF so he may not command and outrageous salary.

Now, launch your bombs at me.
No thanks.
 
If McElwain doesn't pick it up at Florida, then Florida would be a good spot for Chip. I could see Chip sit out of coaching for a year or so, and then head to the Gators.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT