I have no idea what that poster was talking about?
There are plenty of neighborhoods that are walkable and have lovely restaurants and bars. I visit them all the time.
In addition to Squirrel Hill and Shadyside, Regent Square is positively lovely. Aspinwall and Sewickley look like they were created by a Pottery Barn set designer.
Have you been the Carnegie lately? There are some high-end restaurants and cool bars popping up in Carnegie. With any luck they could become the next Bridgeville - which is one of the cutest towns in Western Pennsylvania.
As far as the walkable neighborhood thing goes, it is a little bit overrated. You don't have to live there. Most people drive to those business areas and then shop, eat, drink, etc.
Take Mount Lebanon as an example because it's walkability is its primary selling point. Believe me when I tell you that I know that community extremely well.
What percentage of Mount Lebanon homes do you think are within legitimate walking distance of Washington Road (19S)? I mean I get that it is feasible for almost anyone who lives in Mount Lebanon to walk to Washington Road. However, how many people are actually going to do it? I would say less than 10%.
Agree about Mt Lebanon. I also agree with the previous post that compared to many other metro areas, Pittsburgh really does not have a lot of "walkable, centralized" communities that are very attractive to young, growing families. It's one thing to have nice shops and businesses, but if the school system sucks, it takes a lot away. We are in Chicago a lot. I could rattle off so many communities that fit the original description (with the knowledge that real estate in Chicago suburbs wherever you turn is usually dramatically higher compared to Pittsburgh). My husband is from Barrington - lovely downtown, walkable areas and very strong schools. I also agree with the other post about the challenges of the Pittsburgh topography. I still remember my first trip to my in-laws. Riding back form O'Hara, my MIL pointed out that Barrington is a bit more "hillier" than other areas in the region. Literally it was just tiny bumps compared to Pittsburgh.
However, all of those bakeries, bars, bistro's, pizza shops, etc. stay in business. So how do they do it? They do it because people like me drive there, park, and then spend the next few hours eating, drinking, shopping, etc.