Hell, I'll give Cat 41 points -- same as TJ Warren -- just make sure you show up on the boards.
That was the ultimate example of one guy not being able to kill you on his own, IMO. Pitt outshot NCST in all facets that game, but NCST attempted 13 more FG (and 2 more FT) because they kicked Pitt's ass on the glass. I remember calling that L from my hotel room, Pitt shot some unsustainably high percent in the first half and got killed on the glass so you knew it would flip in the 2nd half if they didn't clean up the board work.
If a guy is going to get his, that's fine, just make sure you contain everybody else and rebound his misses. One guy alone won't beat you for 40 minutes.