Facts - SM has been a head coach for 11 years at 2 different institutions of higher learning, 5 at Xavier and 6 at AZU. He has taken 4 teams to the elite 8 and 2 additional teams to the sweet 16. In 5 years at Xavier he had an elite 8 and a sweet 16. During his 12 years, JD has 1 elite 8 and 2 sweet 16 appearances.
According to Rivals, SM's recruiting classes the past 5 years have been ranked 2, 4, 4, 3, and 4 (Far better than his predecessor at AZU did and far better than JD ever did).
I do no feel like doing the research, but I am pretty sure that during SM's years at Xavier of the A10, he out-recruited Pitt of the Big East. Obviously, he has bettered Pitt by a wide margin during his AZU tenure.
These are the facts, but please don't let them get in the way of your narrative.