Should the non fumble have been

[gary2]

Grounding?

Also - I say a clear hook/hold on a Criswell scramble pass that set up a 4th and one.

 

[TheWerewolfFromTwilight]

They don't call grounding if a defender hits your arm and influences the destination of the ball.

 

[wbrpanther]

Grounding?

Also - I say a clear hook/hold on a Criswell scramble pass that set up a 4th and one.

I thought you had to have CLEAR evidence to overturn a call. That wasn’t clear evidence. Was the ball in his hand or on his hand when his arm went forward?

 

[TheWerewolfFromTwilight]

I thought you had to have CLEAR evidence to overturn a call. That wasn’t clear evidence. Was the ball in his hand or on his hand when his arm went forward?

It seemed pretty clear to anyone not suffering from multiple cataracts. I was actually pissed they didn't blow that dead and let our guys get gassed running to the end zone. The ball doesn't travel in that direction at that velocity when it's fumbled.

 

[gary2]

They don't call grounding if a defender hits your arm and influences the destination of the ball.

He did not even attempt to do anything with the ball until he was hit.

There was no target. He was hoping for arm moving forward.

 

[upj87]

I thought you had to have CLEAR evidence to overturn a call. That wasn’t clear evidence. Was the ball in his hand or on his hand when his arm went forward?

It was clear to Stevie Wonder...geez it was obvious as hell and is called as such 100% of the time.

 

[HopeandChangeforAntoons]

It was the right call. It was clearly a pass attempt and they aren’t calling grounding because it’s impossible to discern intended receiver as he’s getting hit.

 

[upj87]

It was the right call. It was clearly a pass attempt and they aren’t calling grounding because it’s impossible to discern intended receiver as he’s getting hit.

enough of the common sense...it has no place here...

 

[cashisking884]

100% a pass and it wasn’t even close. That’s why the review didn’t take long.

 

[Zeldas Open Roof]

this is a play that you watch and if you are a UNC fan, it very clearly shows that his arm was moving forward and if you are a pitt fan, it very clearly shows that the ball was not in control of his hand when the ball was moving forward.

 

[Burgh15]

100% a pass and it wasn’t even close. That’s why the review didn’t take long.

It was obvious enough that you questioned that they even missed it in real time.

 

[PittPharm2002]

this is a play that you watch and if you are a UNC fan, it very clearly shows that his arm was moving forward and if you are a pitt fan, it very clearly shows that the ball was not in control of his hand when the ball was moving forward.

I’m a pitt fan it was clearly a throw

 

[buckage]

this is a play that you watch and if you are a UNC fan, it very clearly shows that his arm was moving forward and if you are a pitt fan, it very clearly shows that the ball was not in control of his hand when the ball was moving forward.

100% a throw