The coaches are picking the seniors, placing them on two squads, and then the seniors will draft the rest of the team. Then they'll play against each other, and presumably keep score like in a real game, not by some crazy point system.
Originally posted by thebadby2:
Captain, not to nitpick you, but with all due respect I think you have a few misconceptions in your post.........
"Coach Pat just has his own way of doing things since he comes from being Coach's Son."
Not quite accurate. He picked up most of this stuff from being attached to Dantonio's hip for 10-plus years, this is exactly the way Dantonio runs his spring games as well. Of course, Duzzi had a lot of influence over the way things were done at MSU, Dantonio was not too egotistical to give his most trusted staffers a lot of influence and input. But this spring game format is Dantonio's way. Narduzzi's personality comes from his father, but as for his coaching philosophy, he has made no bones about his intention to copy what he and Dantonio did at MSU as closely as possible. So far, that is exactly what he has done. When he was hired, I really hoped he'd do exactly that, basically be a Dantonio clone. And why wouldn't he? Look at their results.
I agree with you that Mark Dantonio without question has help mold Coach Pat's Coaching philosophy, but Mark Dantonio is a "No Nonsense Coach" whom I have admired for years and just goes about quietly doing what he expects from his Staff and Players. I also agree as you point out the Spring Game is a copy of MSU System under Coach D.
In addition, Coach Narduzzi was part of Coach Dantonio's success as much as Jackie Sherrill was part of Johnny Majors in my opinion.
Finally, it is my belief some great coaches come from Father's that raised their kids to join them in coaching. I cite Tony Bennett at UVA, Sean and Archie Miller, and some day I believe Tyler Palko will be one too. Now of course there are just as many failures like Jay Paterno, Beamer, and others. What I really like are Players that were coached by great Coaches and became great Coaches too, like Bear Bryant's Jackie Sherrill or Pop Warner's Jock Sutherland.
However, all of our expectations are worthless until we se Coach Pat win at Pitt as a Head Coach. Although I am very excited about coach Pat, I was the same for Harris, Wannstedt, Graham, and Chryst and all won at Pitt but seldom at a consistent 10+ game level like Dantonio! Until we see it, it is right now irrelevant except for portending expectations.
2. It will create Two Teams of Players on both Offense and
Defense to be an evaluation of each player at positions and not just
a drill. Players will be able to show their weaknesses and strengths.
The coaches are not emphasizing player evaluation based on this spring game in which the first, second and third teamers will be all mixed up playing with different groups than they practice and scrimmage with. It's more about creating some competition, letting the players have some fun, play loose and get after it while giving the fans some entertainment. When I played we did something similar to this, it was more about letting us blow off some steam and have some fun than anything else. The everyday practices are where the individual evaluations take place. Let's just hope nobody gets hurt, because guys will be flying around with a little more energy than usual trying to make highlight reel plays. I'm sure the QBs will be wearing the red jerseys.
I played too, and we scrimmage and play against another school in a scrimmage, this is going to be a Spring Game for evaluation of Coach Pat's Staff and Players. If Coach Pat was choosing the players and handing them over to the coaches I would agree with you. Yet, these Coaches chose the players and like the article says will choose what positions the players will be evaluating? This to me shows the Coaches are being evaluated as ell by coach Pat since they have some autonomy in choosing the players and positions and will be calling the plays and that is far different than what Harris, Wannstedt, Graham, and Chryst did. Sure every day practices is where evaluations take place, but that changes when game day arrives. This is the process of all new Coaches do, but Coach Pat is making his Coaches and Players after all these Spring Practices finally produce in a Scrimmage Game that will show their skills and calls in a game, not a drill or practice. It is a step up from prior practices and scheduled scrimmages as far as I am concern. Competition as you describe is in every practice, scrimmage and especially in every game.
3. The Coaches will be also be learning among themselves and be evaluated by coach Pat Narduzzi on their own coaching.
Again, not really. That's what they do all day in practice and in film study. The coaches will be coaching, but their primary objective will not be to prove anything--it will really be about getting the players fired up and motivated. This is more about rewarding the players for all their hard work this spring.
No matter what, it should be a lot more entertaining than it has been in many years.
Again, disagree with due respect, the coaches are choosing the players that in itself is a decision they are making, and playing them in certain positions another call they are making, and choosing the plays for the game, What you describe above is just another practice or scrimmage as far as I am concern that is happening at very practice.
After this Spring Game is over, I have no question Coach Pat will ask his Coaches why did you choose this player at this position, how to feel he performed and is it the right call, and together they will be able to evaluate these players on how they played, as well as his coaches on how, why, and they made their selections and calls as well.
It is like Coach Pat said, he is the CEO, but he has to evaluate his staff and players uses delegation to make sure they are getting the job done, and that is different from practices and scrimmages, it is now a simulation game for new head Coach to look at his Coaches on how they are choosing to coach their Players .
Finally, it is also a great way to attract fans, and former player alumni, recruits and for the second time in my life, I am thinking of going to the Spring "Game" (Not The Spring "Scrimmage").
Although I can agree with many things you posted, we can agree to disagree on the differences, but this how I see it!