I think I have been the only one critical of Lyke on this board. Football has the lowest talent level since Majors 2 and men's basketball, despite it looking like Capel has turned the corner still isnt winning at a level which pleases everybody. I do like Capel and think he has the program in the right spot going forward. This season should be his best team.
I dont think football or basketball success had as much to do with this decision as the decision to build Victory Heights. I have said over and over that that was a terrible decision. TERRIBLE. And to make things worse, the university had to debt finance most of it. Imagine Gabel's surprise when she took a look at the university's financial record and she sees a large quarterly bond interest expense being paid for an arena for teams who already have an arena. And yea, I know, the Field House is a dump at this point but the 3 sports dont make money. Money matters and Pitt never has enough. Volleyball has shown they dont need a new arena to compete. Maybe they would have lost Fisher if they didnt build the arena, but really, so what. Its nice to have a great volleyball program but most Pitt fans dont go to their games or watch them on TV. Its nice that they are good but its not needed.
Pitt has 2 pro sports. I am sorry but this is what it is. And these arent even "minor league" as some people say. These are major revenue producers....almost NHL-level in terms of revenue. College football is the #2 sport in America. College basketball is #5 ahead of NHL and MLS. Pitt needs these programs to keep most if its money instead of redistributing to pay for Olympic Sports. There's just not enough to go around or to be wasted on a volleyball arena. I also wonder if the fact it was built in really the only place a football stadium could go futher irked her. The Pete is 22 years old. College arenas have a long shelf life but if we had the money, we could have knocked it down and wedged in a 45K seat football stadium and new 9K seat basketball arena there.
I think being late to the NIL game and Pitt's lack of emphasis on fundraising played a part but I think she deserved to be cut some slack here. I dont think a lot of people envisioned NIL to just be pay for play. All of the schools, Pitt included are committing major NCAA violations but the NCAA isnt enforcing anything.
All this said, I wouldn't have fired her. I was hoping she got the NW job or another job. But maybe the financials on the volleyball arena are just that bad. Also, the timing of this is terrible. You dont do it right after the best comeback in years. And not during Brawl Week. It could have waited.