Untrue. If something is a valid criticism, I don't say anything. I am sure you are used to your mom being criticized, and the way you turned out, well she should be.
Almost nobody, and I mean it, almost nobody, wanted to keep him here based on how he looked in games last year. He may have continued to heal or whatever, but that isn't always foreseeable. If your criticism is Jamie isn't all knowing of what someone's long term prognosis is with a a bad micro fracture condition in his knee, then you are really reaching the bottom of the barrel in some strange attempt to find criticism anywhere you can. Valid or not.