ADVERTISEMENT

OT: The Twilight Zone

if you say so.....

So it’s not across the board a Top 5 episode.

You should also read what I wrote.

What I said was that his episodes are not in the classic scripts.

Meaning the episodes that everybody thinks of when they think of the show.

The lists you provided don’t have the Shatner mystic seer episode ranked very high.

But the “Middle of Beyond” reversible Twilight Zone jacket I have has that image of the Seer on the back.

The valet tray I have on my office desk has that on it.

You can buy a replica of it.

Etc.

So while it’s not a critic favorite, to the average person on the street that has some awareness of “classic” episodes, or to the person willing to buy Twilight Zone merch, it’s an essential episode that embodies the show.

My point is that Klugman, while being in 4 episodes, was never given one of those episodes.
 
So it’s not across the board a Top 5 episode.

You should also read what I wrote.

What I said was that his episodes are not in the classic scripts.

Meaning the episodes that everybody thinks of when they think of the show.

The lists you provided don’t have the Shatner mystic seer episode ranked very high.

But the “Middle of Beyond” reversible Twilight Zone jacket I have has that image of the Seer on the back.

The valet tray I have on my office desk has that on it.

You can buy a replica of it.

Etc.

So while it’s not a critic favorite, to the average person on the street that has some awareness of “classic” episodes, or to the person willing to buy Twilight Zone merch, it’s an essential episode that embodies the show.

My point is that Klugman, while being in 4 episodes, was never given one of those episodes.
So it’s not across the board a Top 5 episode... ok, top 10 or so. pretty sure I could find several lists where that is the case but alas I will cede the field of battle as this seems very, very important to you..
 
So it’s not across the board a Top 5 episode... ok, top 10 or so. pretty sure I could find several lists where that is the case but alas I will cede the field of battle as this seems very, very important to you..
are you guys arguing about whether a specific twilight zone episode is a top 5 or top 10 episode?

that's great..
 
Not to mention a bunch of hot chicks from that era....I'm talk'n bout you Nancy Kulp, you vixen...

Unfortunately Klugman was never given any of the classic scripts,... you're joking, right? The "A Game of Pool" episode is generally consider a top five 'classic' episode across the board...

Nancy is a famed Florida State grad. Would have supported the GOR no doubt.

“A Game of Pool” is absolutely a classic.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT