Despite what all these people think, I love the buccos and all my Burgh sports. FWIW I do hope he bounces back next season and they can keep him around, but if not, maybe they get some return on him, if he hits like Cutch again.
At this point, I believe the best they can do is hope for some kind of a bounce back. I think an extension is out the window.
They're hesitant to extend any old guy beyond a couple years at this point, and unfortunately Cutch is showing signs of aging (K's are increasing, defensive range is decreasing, power is declining, etc.). He's not looking like a guy who might age super gracefully, which is unfortunate.
Those guys are exceedingly rare, though, and my theory is they tend to be corner OF and 3B type. Up the middle guys are too reliant on speed and 1B tend to be large frames and power-heavy.