I'm looking at QB's who were uber-dominant and their greatness still looks really impressive in retrospect. Who you got as the best?
EDIT (Why I didn't include the people you're mentioning, not that you're wrong):
**Vince Young isn't here since his #'s really don't fit in with these other guys (especially his interceptions and so-so passing #'s until his last year).
**Sam Bradford was my final cut - maybe could have put him in but I had to cut the list somewhere & I was hoping to have it to 5. You're right; his injury hurt him.
**Tommie Frazier was over 20 years ago.
**Philip Rivers had that 1 great year, but only finished 4th among QB's in Heisman voting that year -- kind of a stretch for a list like this.
**Jason White ... hahahaha
**Pat White was fun to watch & is still the only QB to win 4 bowls, but he never finished higher than 6th in Heisman voting - hard to put on a list like this.
EDIT (Why I didn't include the people you're mentioning, not that you're wrong):
**Vince Young isn't here since his #'s really don't fit in with these other guys (especially his interceptions and so-so passing #'s until his last year).
**Sam Bradford was my final cut - maybe could have put him in but I had to cut the list somewhere & I was hoping to have it to 5. You're right; his injury hurt him.
**Tommie Frazier was over 20 years ago.
**Philip Rivers had that 1 great year, but only finished 4th among QB's in Heisman voting that year -- kind of a stretch for a list like this.
**Jason White ... hahahaha
**Pat White was fun to watch & is still the only QB to win 4 bowls, but he never finished higher than 6th in Heisman voting - hard to put on a list like this.
Last edited: