On this issue of whether these FCS guys can recruit at the FBS level:
1. Recruiting is sales--the quality and desirability of the product you're selling is the most important part of the equation. These FCS guys now have a lot more to sell on the recruiting trail. They will not be hunting FCS talent. Nor will they be pulling top 20 classes, because they are handicapped by the product they are selling.
2. Beyond the product, recruiting is hustle and putting in the time and effort. These new guys are young, ambitious and hungry. We had a bunch of guys with one ass cheek in their lazy-boys out there, understandably sick andtired of leaving their familes constantly to hit the road and grovel to entitled 18 year old kids for months at a time. They became jaded and simply weren't hungry anymore, and I don;t blame them. I suspect we will now at least see a more energetic, dynamic effort.
3. Let's face it--we had a couple of good recruiters on the staff that we lost, Partridge being foremost among them. But most of the guys on the offensive side--Powell, Salem, Cig, Borbs--were NOT getting it done. Period. And Narduzzi has not proven to be any kind of closer that has the juice and charisma to swing a kid with a strong offer sheet--especially on the offensive side.
4. Is there anyone who can say with a straight face that they were energized and optmistic going into the thick of the recruiting season the past several years? I for one am just happy to have some recruiting intrigue and optimism to look forward to.
5. Major changes were needed. We weren't gonna go out and find some 32 year old Joe Brady/Ben Johnson/Kendall Briles wunderkind from another FBS program or from the NFL. So I think Narduzi, to his credit, did what he felt was the next best thing. It's a gamble, but so was Cignetti. The difference is, this time the outcome of the gamble is not a foregone conclusion.
Pretty much. Borbs and Powell were on cruise control. Powell's special teams have been deteriorating for years. No clue what was going on with the RBs last year. Can't say there was much improvement with the OL either. Guys weren't really getting better.
Salem seemed like a good dude, but geeze the TE position has been a problem for years.
Cignetti was a disaster who recruited and started a QB with a dead arm. Our best QB was relegated to 3rd string.
I have no idea how good the new guys are, but it won't be hard to be an improvement. How much of an improvement will be the key.