much coverage or conversation about the Carter move to RB. I am surprised by that
I am talking about the PG, The Trib, the Pitt website, Pgh Sports Now, the powers that be on this website, etc..Do you have amnesia?
You started a post about it on Wednesday and it's about halfway down the page.
There were write ups on the Campbell and the Wheeler moves. I would actually like to see someone comment on Carter at RB. As it is, it is just a change I noticed on the roster listing.He was moved to offense last year. Moving from wr to rb and you want him to make headlines in the papers? He had like 3 big games last year. Stop the presses!
I would like to see him get 15 carries a scrimmage in the spring just to test what he is capable of. I think he can be extremely effective with that kind of load.He was in essence a running back who didn't go through the tackles last year.
Here's his run vs receiving production once he started playing last year:
"…rushed for 202 yards and two touchdowns on 25 carries (8.1 avg.) and also had three catches for nine yards on the year…"
https://pittsburghpanthers.com/roster.aspx?rp_id=10191
I would be surprised if much changed this season, because I don't see him as an every down running back.
Agree. Expect Whipple to be a huge improvement over Watson.I think he will have a lot more receptions this year. I think they will try to get him in a position where he catches the ball and is immediately an open field runner.
Motion out for screen passes.I think he will have a lot more receptions this year. I think they will try to get him in a position where he catches the ball and is immediately an open field runner.
I would like to see him get 15 carries a scrimmage in the spring just to test what he is capable of. I think he can be extremely effective with that kind of load.
KDKA interrupted prime time programming to announce it, what are you talking about?I am talking about the PG, The Trib, the Pitt website, Pgh Sports Now, the powers that be on this website, etc..
Normally, I'd agree. But then I think about Willie Parker - who didn't break many tackles either, but he had three years when he rushed for over 1,000 yds. Guys with that kinda speed are dangerous: one missed defensive assignment, and they're gone.I would be surprised if much changed this season, because I don't see him as an every down running back.
Yep, just a few miles north of me.Normally, I'd agree. But then I think about Willie Parker - who didn't break many tackles either, but he had three years when he rushed for over 1,000 yds. Guys with that kinda speed are dangerous: one missed defensive assignment, and they're gone.
BTW, did you know that Willie Parker is an assistant coach at Heritage HS, (Wake Forest), which is in your general vicinity if you're in Raleigh.
Thanks for posting the video...that was the first time that I'd seen it.
I am talking about the PG, The Trib, the Pitt website, Pgh Sports Now, the powers that be on this website, etc..
If he can produce like the NFL Willie Parker we can all be pretty happy I think. Ironically, i don't think College Willie Parker showed as much? That was back in the days the Steelers were still finding hidden gems at times. Maybe they did so again with Samuel...Normally, I'd agree. But then I think about Willie Parker - who didn't break many tackles either, but he had three years when he rushed for over 1,000 yds. Guys with that kinda speed are dangerous: one missed defensive assignment, and they're gone.
BTW, did you know that Willie Parker is an assistant coach at Heritage HS, (Wake Forest), which is in your general vicinity if you're in Raleigh.
His college coach, John Bunting, allegedly wanted to build a power-style running game and wanted Parker to bulk-up to fit that mold. So Parker languished on the bench his final three years at UNC.If he can produce like the NFL Willie Parker we can all be pretty happy I think. Ironically, i don't think College Willie Parker showed as much? That was back in the days the Steelers were still finding hidden gems at times. Maybe they did so again with Samuel...
He also had academic and discipline issuesHis college coach, John Bunting, allegedly wanted to build a power-style running game and wanted Parker to bulk-up to fit that mold. So Parker languished on the bench his final three years at UNC.
When Parker broke out with the Steelers there were UNC fans who used that as a further reason to want Bunting gone (as if the W-L record wasn't enough).His college coach, John Bunting, allegedly wanted to build a power-style running game and wanted Parker to bulk-up to fit that mold. So Parker languished on the bench his final three years at UNC.
Gary, you have a tendency to believe what coaches say. Most of it is coach-speak. What you need to do is watch what moves they actually make.much coverage or conversation about the Carter move to RB. I am surprised by that
Thanks for the reply. I am in agreement.Gary, you have a tendency to believe what coaches say. Most of it is coach-speak. What you need to do is watch what moves they actually make.
The real question with Carter is whether he is REALLY getting a trial at RB, or is the move mostly about having only two healthy RB's on the roster for the Spring?
Given they signed a smurf speed guy in the 2019 class (who msy or may not RS) we could look at the move either way.
They badly need depth for the Spring, so he could be there just as a body, or he could be there to give Whipple another weapon in his multiple offense.
It probably doesn't bode well for Carter ever getting integrated into the passing game as a WR though.
I suspect Carter is sort of another Q Henderson, neither fish nor foul, who will mainly run jet sweeps and catch screen and flare passes.
In a sense, that's a shame. He is not that different physically from Dorsett or Willy Parker. He probably doesn't have the top end breakaway speed both had, but his quickness for the first 15-20 yards is pretty close. He COULD be a weapon, but a fairly ordinary high school career probably means he's missing something, perhaps the instincts that turn a guy from just a speed-burner to a star.
We'll see if he gets a real chance or is just glorified practice fodder.
well he's getting a chance to get real reps in spring ball. That's a good thing. even if, deep down in the heads of the staff, he isn't better than the incoming freshmen and only there to take reps, at least he's given a chance to get reps and show if he has anything. Who cares how he gets the reps or why, use this as a way to showcase to the staff that you belong..Gary, you have a tendency to believe what coaches say. Most of it is coach-speak. What you need to do is watch what moves they actually make.
The real question with Carter is whether he is REALLY getting a trial at RB, or is the move mostly about having only two healthy RB's on the roster for the Spring?
Given they signed a smurf speed guy in the 2019 class (who msy or may not RS) we could look at the move either way.
They badly need depth for the Spring, so he could be there just as a body, or he could be there to give Whipple another weapon in his multiple offense.
It probably doesn't bode well for Carter ever getting integrated into the passing game as a WR though.
I suspect Carter is sort of another Q Henderson, neither fish nor foul, who will mainly run jet sweeps and catch screen and flare passes.
In a sense, that's a shame. He is not that different physically from Dorsett or Willy Parker. He probably doesn't have the top end breakaway speed both had, but his quickness for the first 15-20 yards is pretty close. He COULD be a weapon, but a fairly ordinary high school career probably means he's missing something, perhaps the instincts that turn a guy from just a speed-burner to a star.
We'll see if he gets a real chance or is just glorified practice fodder.
PG beat writer got back to me - He doesn't have any clear impression at this time - Said things will become more apparent as spring practice continues - Nobody seems to have the interest in this I do (You know me. I tend to focus on individual favorites:Gary, you have a tendency to believe what coaches say. Most of it is coach-speak. What you need to do is watch what moves they actually make.
The real question with Carter is whether he is REALLY getting a trial at RB, or is the move mostly about having only two healthy RB's on the roster for the Spring?
Given they signed a smurf speed guy in the 2019 class (who msy or may not RS) we could look at the move either way.
They badly need depth for the Spring, so he could be there just as a body, or he could be there to give Whipple another weapon in his multiple offense.
It probably doesn't bode well for Carter ever getting integrated into the passing game as a WR though.
I suspect Carter is sort of another Q Henderson, neither fish nor foul, who will mainly run jet sweeps and catch screen and flare passes.
In a sense, that's a shame. He is not that different physically from Dorsett or Willy Parker. He probably doesn't have the top end breakaway speed both had, but his quickness for the first 15-20 yards is pretty close. He COULD be a weapon, but a fairly ordinary high school career probably means he's missing something, perhaps the instincts that turn a guy from just a speed-burner to a star.
We'll see if he gets a real chance or is just glorified practice fodder.
Dave Olinger. -I haven't heard that name in years. The 3-point shot might have made some guys a bit more relevant if thev were around now.PG beat writer got back to me - He doesn't have any clear impression at this time - Said things will become more apparent as spring practice continues - Nobody seems to have the interest in this I do (You know me. I tend to focus on individual favorites:
Pickett, McGowens,P.Stewart,D.Prietley, J.Johnson, L.Kendall, T.Glover, Dave (the Big O) Olinger, etc)
Back in the day, I used to hang out with some of Majors' 85 or 90 freshmen. Even before that, I hooped with a bunch of DePasqua's younger guys. I played, poorly, in high school. I was big but blew out a knee my senior year. I thought about walking on, but when a trainer looked at my knee, he said no way.well he's getting a chance to get real reps in spring ball. That's a good thing. even if, deep down in the heads of the staff, he isn't better than the incoming freshmen and only there to take reps, at least he's given a chance to get reps and show if he has anything. Who cares how he gets the reps or why, use this as a way to showcase to the staff that you belong..
If he doesn't and is passed over when the incoming freshmen backs get on campus, then no loss. Worst case, they'll move him back to WR and he'll be the "jet sweep" guy. It's not like he could have turned into an all conference WR but since he missed the reps in spring ball, that window will close and never re-open..
20+ touches per game? What? If he is getting 20+ touches per game, he is your starting every down back.Carter was by far our mosrt electric playmaker on offense with the ball in his hands. I dont see him as an every down back just yet, but he should still be getting 20+ touches per game. Big move, this will help Pickett on some check downs as well.