ADVERTISEMENT

Best HS stadium?

There are a lot of nice high school campuses out there these days. You even see beautiful stadiums popping up in districts with little money. Crazy how different it's become. When I was in high school, some teams were playing in glorified cornfields.
Arms race, like new dorms in college. My H.S played FB in Villanova's Stadium. 13K, we outdrew the Wildcats. Some of the stadiums in Philly were awful. The world is unbalanced.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HailToPitt725
I actually saw the McKinley- Massillon game at Fawcett when Chris Spielman did the unthinkable and started both ways as a sophomore for the Tigers. Actually I haven't been inside the new digs yet. The old stadium was great.
Have you seen Fawcett lately? They completely redid it. It is awesome! They renamed it Tom Benson Hall of Fame Stadium

maxresdefault.jpg
 
I assume you meant Portage. That is a really quaint old stadium. It was built by the CCC in the 30s. State College is also unique.
I have a wind farm customer right down the street from Portage's football field. And I am pissed that the good pizza shop went out of business (before the COVID crisis).
 
Just after college, my friends and I would get our fall Fridays started by hitting up a WPIAL venue that we had never been to before.

I know what you’re thinking and yes, we really were some wild and crazy guys!

This is actually something I want to do myself, I think that's awesome you were able to do that! I've been to so many through my HS experience and working at games on Friday nights, but eventually want to see some more locations.

I am with you on Pine Richland. It's very nice and had a terrific food selection from what I remember, but those dinky stands on the far side take away from the stadium and I'm just not impressed by press boxes. I get they look nice, but I'm not sitting in them. As you said, it lacks some charm.

I also lump Thomas Jefferson, Montour, South Fayette, and Hampton into a group. They basically all have the same stadium built into a hillside and it feels like you are a mile and a half away from the field. Generally very nice press boxes, but again, that's not where the spectators are sitting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HailToPitt725
For Schools not mentioned many great one already stated.

I do tend to favor older facilities even if they are rougher now then before.

WPIAL
Monessen
Uniontown
New Castle
Deer Lakes

PA outside of WPIAL

State College
Mt Carmel Silver Bowl
Sharon
Postage

Ohio
Warren G Harding
Martin's Ferry
Good call on Martin’s Ferry. That’s another nice Ohio Valley stadium. Been there a few times, love how it’s right by the river, the stands have those old-fashioned overhangs, and they also have no track.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mikefln
I assume you meant Portage. That is a really quaint old stadium. It was built by the CCC in the 30s. State College is also unique.

Yes, I am horrible with not checking if auto correct changed it. My of my post are abominations because of that. Yet I never learn to double check.
 
I've been to Fawcett quite a few times and attended a Massillon-McKinley game at Paul Brown Stadium back in the day.
Yeah I knew the Massillon-McKinley game was big when I moved to the area way back in 1979, when I saw an article on it week of the game on the front page of the Wall St Journal of all places.
 
One stadium that did not make your list but absolutely should have, especially given the other schools included, was Dormont Stadium. That’s probably the best pure venue of any of them.

Their pressbox is horrible and you have to park several blocks away and then walk up basically their version of Cardiac Hill just to get into the stadium. However, it is so worth it. You will see people sitting on their porches — and on the roofs of their porches — just hanging out watching the game. That’s amazing!

Also, I’m not sure if it’s still the case, but I know at one time it hosted three different WPIAL high schools: Keystone Oaks, Bishop Canevin and Seton LaSalle. I am not aware of any other venue they can make the same claim. That has to be on any list.

My home field for 2 of the 3 teams Seton LaSalle and Canevin (before they added Bishop to the name). Seton LaSalle no longer calls it home. Back in the grass field days week one, I would put that field up against any other HS in the country. By week 4 it was the worse surface in HS football because ontop of the 3 varsity teams you mentioned you also had KO's Boy's and Girls Varsity and JV soccer games and the KO pop warner teams all using that field.

As for the stadium itself, yes it is cool. What stops me from mentioning it is, despite not having a track you are still far from the field due to the walk space between the field and stands.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. von Yinzer
Yeah I knew the Massillon-McKinley game was big when I moved to the area way back in 1979, when I saw an article on it week of the game on the front page of the Wall St Journal of all places.
Speaking of North Canton, Hoover also has a very nice stadium. Heard the Vikings had some great games with Steubenville back in the day.
 
Outside of the WPIAL, I’ve really liked watching games at Mechanicsburg and Middletown in the Harrisburg area (and the old Rockpile at Bishop McDevitt, God rest its soul), and also at State College and at Pottsville.

In the WPIAL, I really like North Hills. Canon-Mac has a decent setup, too, and same with Mt. Lebanon. I’ve got a thing for the older stadiums without tracks, and specifically if the stadium isn’t just part of a sprawling school campus somewhere. If it’s in a municipal park or in the middle of a town somewhere, that’s ideal.
 
Speaking of North Canton, Hoover also has a very nice stadium. Heard the Vikings had some great games with Steubenville back in the day.
Hoover’s stadium is nothing special, fairly average as HS football stadiums go.

Their claim to fame w/r to HS FB is being the home of Todd Blackledge. Painfully reminded of it shortly after moving out this way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HailToPitt725
Hoover’s stadium is nothing special, fairly average as HS football stadiums go.

Their claim to fame w/r to HS FB is being the home of Todd Blackledge. Painfully reminded of it shortly after moving out this way.
My nephew went to Canton Lincoln.Played basebll against Blackledge. I was watching the Pitt-UPS game from '79 and Joe brought in Jeff Hostetler in the 3rd quarter. He really looked good as a freshman and I thought Jopa screwed up big time when he tried to move him to LB so Blackledge could start.Jeff was from my area and was a tremendous athlete. He probably could have been an AA linebacker. but he transferred to WVU and went on to a good Pro career including a Super Bowl championship.
 
My home field for 2 of the 3 teams Seton LaSalle and Canevin (before they added Bishop to the name). Seton LaSalle no longer calls it home. Back in the grass field days week one, I would put that field up against any other HS in the country. By week 4 it was the worse surface in HS football because ontop of the 3 varsity teams you mentioned you also had KO's Boy's and Girls Varsity and JV soccer games and the KO pop warner teams all using that field.

As for the stadium itself, yes it is cool. What stops me from mentioning it is, despite not having a track you are still far from the field due to the walk space between the field and stands.
Yeah, I could see that. Also, I can’t even imagine that as a grass field, because you’re right, the traffic it had on it had to be unbelievable!

However, there was definitely a magic to that stadium. I absolutely loved it! I always rave about it to anyone who will listen. It’s got to be in the top five.
 
Canon-Mac is a good call too. Again, that is Western PA to its core. You literally have to drive across the train tracks to get there.

I heard that whenever they were developing Southpointe, the developers offered Canonsburg the opportunity to build for free their high school in Southpointe with a new football stadium and all the rest of it. However, for whatever reason, they were rebuffed. I don’t know if that’s true or not, but that is definitely what I’ve heard. If that is true, that’s was a criminally idiotic decision by the Canonsburg brain trust.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Panther Parrothead
Canon-Mac is a good call too. Again, that is Western PA to its core. You literally have to drive across the train tracks to get there.

Scenery, I agree WPA to the core. Watching a game from the visitors side... that place is awful. Sits so low you can barley see over the team standing on the sideline. Not sure if home stands are any better as I never sat there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HailToPitt725
The worst field was where Duquesne HS played. They didn’t even have full size end zones. The corner was cut off. The locker rooms were awful as well.

Hey, those were regulation end zones. Anyone who didn't think so was welcome to use their own tape measure to verify. I can understand (and almost sympathize) with visitors who were intimidated by the concrete wall in the corner of the south end zone, though.
 
Yeah, that was a dump. And they've since merged with West Mifflin, who used to play at their middle school field, which was like 15 minutes away from their high school. But I think they have a pretty decent stadium at their high school now.

That was the home field at the former West Mifflin South High School (back when West Mifflin had two high schools at opposite ends of town). The most distinctive feature I recall of that field was that the field was carved into a hillside, and the visitor's sideline (ours) was a few steps from the edge of a cliff . . .
 
  • Like
Reactions: HailToPitt725
Just after college, my friends and I would get our fall Fridays started by hitting up a WPIAL venue that we had never been to before.

I know what you’re thinking and yes, we really were some wild and crazy guys!

Anyway, it just became something we would do and it was fun. From there, we would usually hit a bar or a few bars nearby and usually talk about football.

I’m not that old but two of the guys that would do that with me are now dead, so time goes quickly.

We talked about writing a book about it or something like that, but it just never materialized. I don’t know if it was interesting enough for that? I’m not sure there’s a huge market for football nerds who love high school football stadiums specifically in Western Pennsylvania?

Anyway, eventually it just petered out because we started to have children or moved to a different city or whatever. Also, I started going to more Pitt road games, which obviously coincides with that.

However, every once in a blue moon I will get a call from someone saying, “Hey, let’s go to a couple football games this fall.”

Now, we typically go back and visit just our favorite sites and I agree that to be considered elite, you can’t have a track around your field. That’s a real dealbreaker for intimacy reasons.

Pine-Richland, for example, is absolutely opulent. However, it lacks the charm and some of those other places have. The press box is absolutely absurd though. It’s legitimately unbelievable. Still, there’s no way in hell I would put that in my top five WPIAL Stadium experiences.

I would rank Martorelli Stadium as my favorite WPIAL venue. It just has a really cool vibe to it right in the middle of Ross Township. It just feels like a throwback experience. I was there many times before they renovated it and I’ve been there several times after they’ve renovated it and even though they changed a lot about it, including the direction of the field itself, it has still maintained its charm.

I also loved Greensburg Salem! It also had a great feel. It felt like a throwback and I loved that. I can’t recommend it highly enough.

Ambridge is cool too and bonus points for Ambridge is that Frank’s Pizza is literally another block down the street and that’s one of the best pizza places in the region as well. Go to a game at Ambridge and grab a pie from Frank’s and you will definitely not be disappointed.

One stadium that did not make your list but absolutely should have, especially given the other schools included, was Dormont Stadium. That’s probably the best pure venue of any of them.

Their pressbox is horrible and you have to park several blocks away and then walk up basically their version of Cardiac Hill just to get into the stadium. However, it is so worth it. You will see people sitting on their porches — and on the roofs of their porches — just hanging out watching the game. That’s amazing!

Also, I’m not sure if it’s still the case, but I know at one time it hosted three different WPIAL high schools: Keystone Oaks, Bishop Canevin and Seton LaSalle. I am not aware of any other venue they can make the same claim. That has to be on any list.

You also have the Pit (Aliquippa) and the Wolverina ( Woodland Hills), which are as famous for the quality of their teams as they are the venues themselves, but the venues themselves are awesome.

Some other underrated ones are Blackhawk – which sits right next to a giant cornfield. I always thought that was really cool.

I like South Fayette a lot too. It reminds me a little of Pine Richland. It’s not one of the very best but it’s absolutely a cool setting on a Friday night. Also, South Fayette’s entire school district sits on one sprawling campus and that is so cool. The whole thing feels like a Division III college. Very cool!

Thomas Jefferson has another cool setting that is very similar to South Fayette. It only has stands on one side but it’s cool. Gateway is like that too.

Also, Deer Lakes is fantastic sitting in that valley. Man, that was a beautiful little venue. Another cool one up that way it was Highlands. They have a bronze ram statue in the one end zone and I thought that was amazing.

I also always liked Upper St. Clair and Mt. Lebanon, which has a big LEBO rock formation up on the hill that surrounds the stadium. At least it did at the time. Also, people would hang out up top and just kind of tailgate and look down into the stadium. That was very cool.

Those were all the ones that stood out to me. I can’t really think of many others. I wasn’t blown away with Hempfield or North Allegheny or Bethel Park or many of the others. They were all kind of the same.

I do remember going to Norwin, but I don’t remember being overwhelmed by it. I thought it was fine but forgettable. I’m surprised it has become such a highly regarded venue. To me, it always felt like Plum or Franklin Regional — one of those cool but not amazing places.
Have you been to Upper St Clair since they added the enormous building? I'm curious what that's like.

YbNS9DtaPZ5N
 
A lot of the old stadiums mentioned were paid for/built by the steel companies. Belle Vernon is one of those. Monesson would fall in that bucket as well. I want to say Charleroi, Clairton, and some of the other small valley towns had similarly histories. I've also always been a fan of HS stadiums where you could enter the stands from the top. Very underappreciated feature that keeps the old guy, who can't climb the steps, coming to games.

Not sure if anyone remembers when Ringgold would play their games in Donora up at Legion Field. I got to play in one of the final games there. The field was build during the depression. It's overgrown and crumbling now but you can find some of these old stadiums if you know where to look. The locker rooms were adjacent and had paper thin walls. The Ringgold players were taught to be silent so they could hear what was being said in the opponent's locker room.

Side note on Belle Vernon. That turf is an abomination but it was never was a good grass field. It was actually terrible but mostly because they played, on average, 6-8 games of some sort there per week and they liked to keep the grass short because BV always had smaller, fast teams. But yeah, I don't know too many alumni that think it's okay to be that color.
Belle Vernon Field is one of the worst I’ve ever have seen and been on. Who originally laid the turf screwed it up bad and instead of redoing it correctly they just pulled the padding out. It’s like walking on turf from 1977. And super slick. You can see the water marks where the water puddled under the turf.
 
Yeah, that was a dump. And they've since merged with West Mifflin, who used to play at their middle school field, which was like 15 minutes away from their high school. But I think they have a pretty decent stadium at their high school now.
West Mifflins new facilities are top notch with the new video scoreboard, new turf put in last summer.
 
Chambersburg high school has really nice facilities out there and another nice stadium is Richlands High school out in Johnstown
 
Have you been to Upper St Clair since they added the enormous building? I'm curious what that's like.

YbNS9DtaPZ5N

That is our administration building. It was "built" for this past season but apparently it was not 100% operational plus parking/traffic was still restricted. This upcoming season (if there is one) will be a better judge of how the facility improved.
 
Have you seen Fawcett lately? They completely redid it. It is awesome! They renamed it Tom Benson Hall of Fame Stadium

maxresdefault.jpg
WOW. Last time I was there they were just starting to tear down half of the old stadium.
Yes! Craig Mazz right? Really good pizza. What the heck did he do? I used to buy it for the wind farm guys all the time.
I think he turned out to be some sort of predator. It reopened under new management for a while then closed again.
 
North hills looks pretty cool. The no track thing makes it. Really, if you consider it a great football venue, it’s not gonna have a track. North hills is one of a very few that has this feature.

there is actually a little restaurant on the hill above it. It’d be cool if that place built a back deck and got a liquor license. The deck would overlook the footbsll stadium. That’d be sweet sitting up there with an outside bar during a Friday night gsme.
No track is key. Rare given the budgetary need for multipurpose utility at 99% of schools, but it makes the stadium.
 
That is our administration building. It was "built" for this past season but apparently it was not 100% operational plus parking/traffic was still restricted. This upcoming season (if there is one) will be a better judge of how the facility improved.
It looks like a very large press box at the top also.
 
mitchell.jpg


Mitchell Stadium in Bluefield, WV. It is shared between the two Bluefields. The Bluefield, VA (Graham HS) school plays all its home and playoff appearances there making it the only school to play it's home games in another state. The state line cuts across the parking lot near the building with the green roof.
Wow. That's pretty impressive.
 
Canon-Mac is a good call too. Again, that is Western PA to its core. You literally have to drive across the train tracks to get there.

I heard that whenever they were developing Southpointe, the developers offered Canonsburg the opportunity to build for free their high school in Southpointe with a new football stadium and all the rest of it. However, for whatever reason, they were rebuffed. I don’t know if that’s true or not, but that is definitely what I’ve heard. If that is true, that’s was a criminally idiotic decision by the Canonsburg brain trust.
The problem with Canon Mac's stadium has always been parking - or the lack of it. On more than one occasion, they had the chance to correct it, but the "decision-makers" were rebuffed by older, very vocal, well-intentioned, but short-sighted people who were deathly afraid that their taxes would increase.

The plan to put everything at the site of what is now "Southpointe" would've put the high school and the stadium centrally located in the school district - that is, the place where the borough of Canonsburg, Cecil Township, and North Strabane Township meet. (It's my understanding that it was an either/or conundrum: school + stadium or Southpointe). Choosing one meant you didn't get the other; choosing school + stadium would've meant that there wouldn't be Southpointe, and from a pure, economic standpoint, Southpointe has attracted a lot of high-end, high tech jobs into an area that was an outdated, dying, mining and (small) manufacturing area. Unfortunately, it meant a trade-off and tough decisions...and I suspect that they might have made a better decision with Southpointe, as painful as it was.

The borough of Canonsburg is basically land-locked re: growth, but Cecil and North Strabane Twps have been booming - making Canon Mac one of the largest school districts in the WPIAL. The growth has affected their high school sports, as they've recently won WPIAL and/or PIAA titles in the so-called "minor" sports (boys/girls soccer, baseball, softball. track-field, girls volleyball, wrestling), but they haven't gotten over-the-hump in football or basketball. And FWIW, their high school band is really impressive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. von Yinzer
That is our administration building. It was "built" for this past season but apparently it was not 100% operational plus parking/traffic was still restricted. This upcoming season (if there is one) will be a better judge of how the facility improved.
Yeah. USC is not a great stadium to watch a game. The lighting is terrible. But overall it’s not a bad place. The thing about the new building is people will rave about “their press box”, without considering it’s an administration building.
 
The problem with Canon Mac's stadium has always been parking - or the lack of it. On more than one occasion, they had the chance to correct it, but the "decision-makers" were rebuffed by older, very vocal, well-intentioned, but short-sighted people who were deathly afraid that their taxes would increase.

The plan to put everything at the site of what is now "Southpointe" would've put the high school and the stadium centrally located in the school district - that is, the place where the borough of Canonsburg, Cecil Township, and North Strabane Township meet. (It's my understanding that it was an either/or conundrum: school + stadium or Southpointe). Choosing one meant you didn't get the other; choosing school + stadium would've meant that there wouldn't be Southpointe, and from a pure, economic standpoint, Southpointe has attracted a lot of high-end, high tech jobs into an area that was an outdated, dying, mining and (small) manufacturing area. Unfortunately, it meant a trade-off and tough decisions...and I suspect that they might have made a better decision with Southpointe, as painful as it was.

The borough of Canonsburg is basically land-locked re: growth, but Cecil and North Strabane Twps have been booming - making Canon Mac one of the largest school districts in the WPIAL. The growth has affected their high school sports, as they've recently won WPIAL and/or PIAA titles in the so-called "minor" sports (boys/girls soccer, baseball, softball. track-field, girls volleyball, wrestling), but they haven't gotten over-the-hump in football or basketball. And FWIW, their high school band is really impressive.
CM stadium is a good place to watch a game. It has that old western PA vibe in an old town and large mature trees around the field. Now that there’s new additional parking and locker rooms, it’s now a good place to host playoff games, which was an issue in the past because of the locker room situation that has since been corrected. It still lacks a good press box though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. von Yinzer
Belle Vernon was mentioned a couple times here.

pro: great for being seated right on top of the field close to the action. I’m sure other stadiums are similar but I’m not sure whose.

con: the surface. The color is awful and the brand is worse. It needs replaced already and it’s not that old.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT