Just after college, my friends and I would get our fall Fridays started by hitting up a WPIAL venue that we had never been to before.
I know what you’re thinking and yes, we really were some wild and crazy guys!
Anyway, it just became something we would do and it was fun. From there, we would usually hit a bar or a few bars nearby and usually talk about football.
I’m not that old but two of the guys that would do that with me are now dead, so time goes quickly.
We talked about writing a book about it or something like that, but it just never materialized. I don’t know if it was interesting enough for that? I’m not sure there’s a huge market for football nerds who love high school football stadiums specifically in Western Pennsylvania?
Anyway, eventually it just petered out because we started to have children or moved to a different city or whatever. Also, I started going to more Pitt road games, which obviously coincides with that.
However, every once in a blue moon I will get a call from someone saying, “Hey, let’s go to a couple football games this fall.”
Now, we typically go back and visit just our favorite sites and I agree that to be considered elite, you can’t have a track around your field. That’s a real dealbreaker for intimacy reasons.
Pine-Richland, for example, is absolutely opulent. However, it lacks the charm and some of those other places have. The press box is absolutely absurd though. It’s legitimately unbelievable. Still, there’s no way in hell I would put that in my top five WPIAL Stadium experiences.
I would rank Martorelli Stadium as my favorite WPIAL venue. It just has a really cool vibe to it right in the middle of Ross Township. It just feels like a throwback experience. I was there many times before they renovated it and I’ve been there several times after they’ve renovated it and even though they changed a lot about it, including the direction of the field itself, it has still maintained its charm.
I also loved Greensburg Salem! It also had a great feel. It felt like a throwback and I loved that. I can’t recommend it highly enough.
Ambridge is cool too and bonus points for Ambridge is that Frank’s Pizza is literally another block down the street and that’s one of the best pizza places in the region as well. Go to a game at Ambridge and grab a pie from Frank’s and you will definitely not be disappointed.
One stadium that did not make your list but absolutely should have, especially given the other schools included, was Dormont Stadium. That’s probably the best pure venue of any of them.
Their pressbox is horrible and you have to park several blocks away and then walk up basically their version of Cardiac Hill just to get into the stadium. However, it is so worth it. You will see people sitting on their porches — and on the roofs of their porches — just hanging out watching the game. That’s amazing!
Also, I’m not sure if it’s still the case, but I know at one time it hosted three different WPIAL high schools: Keystone Oaks, Bishop Canevin and Seton LaSalle. I am not aware of any other venue they can make the same claim. That has to be on any list.
You also have the Pit (Aliquippa) and the Wolverina ( Woodland Hills), which are as famous for the quality of their teams as they are the venues themselves, but the venues themselves are awesome.
Some other underrated ones are Blackhawk – which sits right next to a giant cornfield. I always thought that was really cool.
I like South Fayette a lot too. It reminds me a little of Pine Richland. It’s not one of the very best but it’s absolutely a cool setting on a Friday night. Also, South Fayette’s entire school district sits on one sprawling campus and that is so cool. The whole thing feels like a Division III college. Very cool!
Thomas Jefferson has another cool setting that is very similar to South Fayette. It only has stands on one side but it’s cool. Gateway is like that too.
Also, Deer Lakes is fantastic sitting in that valley. Man, that was a beautiful little venue. Another cool one up that way it was Highlands. They have a bronze ram statue in the one end zone and I thought that was amazing.
I also always liked Upper St. Clair and Mt. Lebanon, which has a big LEBO rock formation up on the hill that surrounds the stadium. At least it did at the time. Also, people would hang out up top and just kind of tailgate and look down into the stadium. That was very cool.
Those were all the ones that stood out to me. I can’t really think of many others. I wasn’t blown away with Hempfield or North Allegheny or Bethel Park or many of the others. They were all kind of the same.
I do remember going to Norwin, but I don’t remember being overwhelmed by it. I thought it was fine but forgettable. I’m surprised it has become such a highly regarded venue. To me, it always felt like Plum or Franklin Regional — one of those cool but not amazing places.