I don’t get the majority of this thread. Where does the expectation that a homegrown player should automatically choose Pitt come from? If I were a Western PA kid growing up over the last 18 years, why exactly do I choose to come to Pitt to play over the likes of ND, Penn St, Michigan, Ohio State or the 40-50 other programs that have outperformed Pitt over that span? Because I want to help resurrect the program? Kids today don’t think that way nor should they. They should go to the program where they feel they fit. If it doesn’t work out, now more than ever they have options to transfer. There is nothing wrong with that.
The bottom line is he never considered Pitt. When you are a ND fan and ND offers, you are likely to go. My wife and in-laws are all alums. It’s one of the strongest networks socially and professionally in the country. Regardless of his performance on the field or NFL aspirations, he is set up for success.
It has never fazed me as a Pitt fan/alumnus that he went to ND. He didn’t surprise me that the coaches recruiting him turned to negativity, particularly the offensive regime at the time. When you aren’t good and you have a player that is clearly not interested, you can focus your effort and energy elsewhere or resort to desperate measures. Negativity is an act of desperation. Since they are on their 3rd OC since that time, I would say he chose wisely given the information he had.
All that being said, it’s not unfathomable he finishes his career elsewhere, maybe even Pitt. I could see him graduate after next year, if he doesn’t get a shot with 2 years of eligibility then transfer.