Natural grass is the way to go. If only we had Louisville money. Soccer recruiting is something Pitt can absolutely turn around. It's not the same as football, where you have the same core schools always dominating. Several years ago, Akron was killing it, Now they aren't even in the top 25. IT also helps that you play more games than in football, so you aren't protecting your schedule like football does. The ACC is the conference to be in for both men's and women's soccer. Maryland, WF, UNC, Clemson, Syracuse, Louisville, ND, UVA, VT are all top 25. That's the competition for Pitt. On the women's side, UVA, Clemson, ND, Duke, FSU, UNC, NC State are all top 25. It's a tough mountain to climb for both programs. But the men are in absolutely great hands. But it'll take some time.
The big reason Akron was so good was their coach. So Louisville hired him away and spent a ton of money on upgrading their facilities. Now, they are a major player.