ADVERTISEMENT

Sans KP, Steelers the worse for wear....

To trade a coach in the NFL, the coach must agree to be traded. The notion that Tomlin is unique in having a no trade clause is ridiculous.
Listen Eleanor, he’s holding the city and fanbase hostage.

Not that it matters because the owner loves mediocrity. As you do too.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: jtownknowitall
Art is the only vote that matters
Hang the “Sell the Team!” Banners
I am approaching the point where I think if the Pirates and Steelers switched ownership, the Pirates would get worse and the Steelers would get better.

Though I will say, I do not understand why Shelton is back. Personally, Tomlin coming back makes more sense to me than Shelton coming back. At least Mike can point to ancient historic playoff success, and .500+ regular seasons. Shelton can't point to anything. I think the Buccos are wasting a full year of Skenes with Shelton managing in 2025.
 
How do we know that a conversation between Tomlin and Rooney didn’t already occur? As I said earlier Tomlin made it pretty clear he has no intention of going anywhere.

And the incompetence, if any, was giving him the no trade clause.
It was leaked like less than a day from the Wild Card loss that Tomlin wasn't going anywhere. Rooney wasn't going to have that talk during the season or a week of playoff prep.
 
Seriously, your Rooney/Tomlin obsession is approaching KennyHeisman8's KP fetish.
Take a breath, perhaps breathe into a paper bag!
Fixed for ya. ^^^

Oh. And maybe you should tell those who cover the team to stop reporting new items every news cycle. Should we pretend these things aren’t happening? It’s the off-season and teams are making changes all around the league. But the Steelers are giving no indication that they are doing anything. When the fans are complacent, it gives the owner all the more reason to be complacent.

But hey maybe the Steelers will get really bold and rearrange some deck chairs.
 
If you want to hear the fanbase really whine!
I know you live out in Appalachia and not close enough or are smart enough to know what’s going on with the fanbase…but a majority of them, those sophisticated enough to know how things work, would cheer on a 3-14 season.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: jtownknowitall
Fixed for ya. ^^^

Oh. And maybe you should tell those who cover the team to stop reporting new items every news cycle. Should we pretend these things aren’t happening? It’s the off-season and teams are making changes all around the league. But the Steelers are giving no indication that they are doing anything. When the fans are complacent, it gives the owner all the more reason to be complacent.

But hey maybe the Steelers will get really bold and rearrange some deck chairs.
Lots of time for them to make their adjustments.
Just Tomlin isn't going to be one of them, and never was.
Franchises that are moving on from their HC's and looking for new ones are active, that's about it. Clearly the Steelers aren't one of those.

NewsFlash: Accrisure will be sold out again next season, Tomlin or no Tomlin.
 
Lots of time for them to make their adjustments.
Just Tomlin isn't going to be one of them, and never was.
Franchises that are moving on from their HC's and looking for new ones are active, that's about it. Clearly the Steelers aren't one of those.

NewsFlash: Accrisure will be sold out again next season, Tomlin or no Tomlin.
The real parallel is the Pens and Steelers ownership. Both think if they just tweak things they’ll get better results. Pens have been doing it longer and are now on the verge of being really bad. Steelers are not far behind

Anyone who thought they’d move on from Tomlin was dreaming. Just like anyone who thinks Tomlin will make any significant changes to his staff is dreaming.

Similarly if anyone thinks Dubas will start the rebuild this year is dreaming.
 
In the abstract, sure. But in the moment, while it's actually happening? You can't really think that. People would be losing their freaking minds.
They absolutely will, sure. But they have the last 4 years too, knowing that the steelers will putter to 9-8 or 10-7 and the season will end in epic fashion and they’ll continue to spin their wheels with no end in sight. They also know that the last losing season yielded a franchise QB in the draft.

Old toothless Eleanor might yell and scream from her barstool at the Carpezzo Bar and Lounge, but she’s doing that anyway.
 
The real parallel is the Pens and Steelers ownership. Both think if they just tweak things they’ll get better results. Pens have been doing it longer and are now on the verge of being really bad. Steelers are not far behind

Anyone who thought they’d move on from Tomlin was dreaming. Just like anyone who thinks Tomlin will make any significant changes to his staff is dreaming.

Similarly if anyone thinks Dubas will start the rebuild this year is dreaming.
Not sure what your definition of "tweaking" is, but the Steelers have some major roster moves to make.
First, decide on QB. More than likely Fields on a 3 year deal.
Figure out the WR room. Either keep Pickens, and add a #1/1A to supplement him, or trade him and sign a top FA WR and pick one high in the draft.
Move Jones over the LT, get him healthy and see if he reaches his potential.
Find a RB replacement for Najee.

Add another top CB either by trade, signing or draft.
Get younger on D line.
Don't expect any major coaching adjustments because they never do, but personally would move Austin out. They won't but should.
 
The real parallel is the Pens and Steelers ownership. Both think if they just tweak things they’ll get better results. Pens have been doing it longer and are now on the verge of being really bad. Steelers are not far behind

Anyone who thought they’d move on from Tomlin was dreaming. Just like anyone who thinks Tomlin will make any significant changes to his staff is dreaming.

Similarly if anyone thinks Dubas will start the rebuild this year is dreaming.


But there are some pretty big differences there. Ownership of the Penguins decided (mostly for ticket selling reasons) that they wanted to keep the old band together for as long as they could, and they have thus limited what changes to the roster the GM can actually make. If Dubas decided the day that he got here that the correct path forward was to blow it all up and start from scratch he would have been prohibited from doing so by ownership.

On the other hand, if Mike Tomlin (and Omar Kahn) decide that blowing up the Stillers is the best path forward and they want to trade away guys like Watt and Fitzpatrick and pile up as many top draft picks as they could, they would have no problem what so ever getting ownership on board.
 
The real parallel is the Pens and Steelers ownership. Both think if they just tweak things they’ll get better results. Pens have been doing it longer and are now on the verge of being really bad. Steelers are not far behind

Anyone who thought they’d move on from Tomlin was dreaming. Just like anyone who thinks Tomlin will make any significant changes to his staff is dreaming.

Similarly if anyone thinks Dubas will start the rebuild this year is dreaming.
I’d be ok with Iron Mike if he brought in a Kingsbury type to lead the offense, and someone to run the defense instead of him. Gotta get a QB first though if you really want to rebuild. Their succession plan drafting Rudolph, then Trubisky, then drafting Pickett, then Russ and Fields was mangled.

Maybe we will be lucky and they will tank next year.
 
I’d be ok with Iron Mike if he brought in a Kingsbury type to lead the offense, and someone to run the defense instead of him. Gotta get a QB first though if you really want to rebuild. Their succession plan drafting Rudolph, then Trubisky, then drafting Pickett, then Russ and Fields was mangled.

Maybe we will be lucky and they will tank next year.
The defense failing is why they lost to end the season
 
The defense failing is why they lost to end the season
They had leads against the Browns and Cowboys into the final minute of each game, and the defense gave up last second TD's to lose both.
Those two wins would have clinched the AFC North, and changed the playoff picture significantly, by at least giving them a home game in the first round.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PittPharm2002
The defense failing is why they lost to end the season
Can’t disagree.

Just about every super bowl over the last couple of decades was won by an elite HOF level QB. Knowing they didn’t have one after Ben, they tried to do it through the highest priced defense. While that isn’t the blueprint for a championship, it should have at least yielded some playoff wins. Instead it yielded blowout loses that the defense lost in the 1st quarter of games.
 
I know you live out in Appalachia and not close enough or are smart enough to know what’s going on with the fanbase…but a majority of them, those sophisticated enough to know how things work, would cheer on a 3-14 season.
Yeah, right! You’re funny. Even out here in Appalachia with all the other branch campus dummies.
 
Yeah, right! You’re funny. Even out here in Appalachia with all the other branch campus dummies.
“Yay! 9-8. Yay! Yay! Keep it going we love non losing, non contending seasons and hampster wheels. “

-nitwits and halfwits

(When the last losing season yielded 3 Super Bowl appearances after drafting Ben)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: jtownknowitall
“Yay! 9-8. Yay! Yay! Keep it going we love non losing, non contending seasons and hampster wheels. “

-nitwits and halfwits

(When the last losing season yielded 3 Super Bowl appearances after drafting Ben)
Are guys like Ben available every year? Don’t forget Trevor Lawrence was the last can’t miss franchise QB. How ‘bout those Jaguars?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Fk_Pitt
But there are some pretty big differences there. Ownership of the Penguins decided (mostly for ticket selling reasons) that they wanted to keep the old band together for as long as they could, and they have thus limited what changes to the roster the GM can actually make. If Dubas decided the day that he got here that the correct path forward was to blow it all up and start from scratch he would have been prohibited from doing so by ownership.

On the other hand, if Mike Tomlin (and Omar Kahn) decide that blowing up the Stillers is the best path forward and they want to trade away guys like Watt and Fitzpatrick and pile up as many top draft picks as they could, they would have no problem what so ever getting ownership on board.
Good point. I was only pointing out both need to be done but neither will. Clearly for different reasons as you pointed out. I suppose the one constant is ownership for both is fine with tweaking
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joe the Panther Fan
They had leads against the Browns and Cowboys into the final minute of each game, and the defense gave up last second TD's to lose both.
Those two wins would have clinched the AFC North, and changed the playoff picture significantly, by at least giving them a home game in the first round.
Highest paid D in the league and not even top 10 rated. Is it coaching or the talent is over rated ?

KC is below 20 in salary on D and they are a top 10 D.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 303vND
Not sure what your definition of "tweaking" is, but the Steelers have some major roster moves to make.
First, decide on QB. More than likely Fields on a 3 year deal.
Figure out the WR room. Either keep Pickens, and add a #1/1A to supplement him, or trade him and sign a top FA WR and pick one high in the draft.
Move Jones over the LT, get him healthy and see if he reaches his potential.
Find a RB replacement for Najee.

Add another top CB either by trade, signing or draft.
Get younger on D line.
Don't expect any major coaching adjustments because they never do, but personally would move Austin out. They won't but should.
Don’t disagree. My point is they need to do ALL those things in addition to making coaching changes (OL and DC) but I doubt they make many of them
 
  • Like
Reactions: FreeportPanther
Are guys like Ben available every year? Don’t forget Trevor Lawrence was the last can’t miss franchise QB. How ‘bout those Jaguars?
How about those Jags! Great example!

Playoff wins in the last 8 years:
Jags 3
Steelers 0

And one of those wins was vs the Steelers as a heavy underdog.

So yeah, they’re just another franchise that has surpassed the Steelers.

You’re not very good at this.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: jtownknowitall
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT