An ugly win is always better than a pretty loss.
It depends on what you are looking for. For instance a one point loss in a well played game at Duke would almost certainly tell us a lot more good things about our team going forward than an overtime win against Mount St. Mary's would. In a year that certain people keep insisting that we not pay attention to wins and losses and only the process, every single one of those folks should prefer the well played, hard fought loss to Duke over the poorly played, crappy overtime win against Mount St. Mary's.