ADVERTISEMENT

WVU - Everything That is Wrong With Education

TheSpecialSauce

Chancellor
Gold Member
Nov 15, 2019
21,016
29,766
113
  • Like
Reactions: pierre93
What’s wrong with that? So the people of WV have to go elsewhere for an arts or humanities degree. In business tough decisions have to get made when some things aren’t sustainable and there are tons of struggling schools out there. I feel bad for those impacted by this, but life comes at you fast sometimes. I was once a victim of a reorganization. It’s not fun. But life goes on. And in this case I know people will use anything they can to pile on the hoopies. But I won’t.
 
No true fan of Pitt would defend these clowns especially on a Pitt message board. Did u ever venture on their board?? They deserve all the jokes and criticism towards them. H2P
Well I'll go with your opinion on what they deserve due to
what they say on their board. However the OP made a few good
points about "reorganization" due to sometimes having programs
that are just not "sustainable."
 
Wondering if they cut the dental program 🤔
See now that’s funny. Well done.

But regarding your previous post, I’m not going to blanket an entire school and their alum because of a silly little rivalry. I won’t prescribe to the tribalism. As a human and Christian, I look for the good in everyone. In my little corner of western PA, I’m surrounded by a lot of hoopies who went to that school. Yes they can get pretty annoying with that stupid little song that wasn’t even written about their state or school…but they are still decent people. Can’t say tht about all of them of course.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HailToPitt1985
I just had to laugh when the first thing I saw in an article titled "West Virginia University Is Everything That’s Wrong With Higher Education Today" was THAT photo of Gee.
 
  • Like
Reactions: singregardless
See now that’s funny. Well done.

But regarding your previous post, I’m not going to blanket an entire school and their alum because of a silly little rivalry. I won’t prescribe to the tribalism. As a human and Christian, I look for the good in everyone. In my little corner of western PA, I’m surrounded by a lot of hoopies who went to that school. Yes they can get pretty annoying with that stupid little song that wasn’t even written about their state or school…but they are still decent people. Can’t say tht about all of them of course.
I wonder then, who they were talking about when they wrote, "stranger to blue water." It might not have started out about West Virginia but it sure as $hit ended up about it.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: FireballZ
I wonder then, who they were talking about when they wrote, "stranger to blue water." It might not have started out about West Virginia but it sure as $hit ended up about it.
I don’t know. But I’m guessing your imagination will tell you that it was about someone somewhere in West Virginia. But people who don’t need to twist the lyrics of a song to give them a sense of self worth will accept that it had nothing to do with a particular state…but if it did it would have been Maryland.

But congrats to West Virginia for phonetically fitting into the meter of the song. Something for you all to be proud of.
 
I don’t know. But I’m guessing your imagination will tell you that it was about someone somewhere in West Virginia. But people who don’t need to twist the lyrics of a song to give them a sense of self worth will accept that it had nothing to do with a particular state…but if it did it would have been Maryland.

But congrats to West Virginia for phonetically fitting into the meter of the song. Something for you all to be proud of.
So true

Denver wasn’t singing about West Virginia at all…

But I guess it goes back to literacy once again
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Fk_Pitt
wvu is just doing what most universities should be doing, cutting out 75% of these undergrad and graduate programs that offer zero benefits to future employment. these programs are scams that offer nothing but a chance for universities to steal money from the American public.
 
wvu is just doing what most universities should be doing, cutting out 75% of these undergrad and graduate programs that offer zero benefits to future employment. these programs are scams that offer nothing but a chance for universities to steal money from the American public.
Couldn’t disagree more. Language, writing , critical thinking , creativity, the arts… all such important skills and worthy pursuits .
 
wvu is just doing what most universities should be doing, cutting out 75% of these undergrad and graduate programs that offer zero benefits to future employment. These programs are scams that offer nothing but a chance for universities to steal money from the American public.
A bit over the top, Zelda. Making cuts due to programs not
being sustainable could be reasonable. The rest of your
post about these types of programs being "scams"
leading to these institutions "stealing money from the
American public" is nothing more than an opinion with
no proof or evidence.
 
skills that can be obtained in other ways than paying 80k to some clown professor at a university.
I suppose you could teach yourself to be a doctor, too, but you'd have a hard time getting licensed. I know that's a bit hyperbolic but it's not as simple as saying some programs are more worthy of pursuit than others. No matter how much some people want to deny the necessity of these academic fields, we used to believe that understanding our history and humanity was important to growing as a species. Schools like WVU gave the residents of their state an avenue to pursue these degrees at a very high level without leaving and the state was eager to finance the college. I don't know when we convinced ourselves that college should become a purely ,for profit, endeavor but I think it does a disservice to the people who wish to stay home and go to school.

Incidentally, I know someone who studied history at WVU who teaches and just wrote a book. I'm told he is a fantastic teacher.
 
skills that can be obtained in other ways than paying 80k to some clown professor at a university.
If you want a straight up “job training” school go vo tech … become a plumber or a mechanic…

A University isn’t just a job training ground… and I have no idea how you’ve deluded yourself into believing many of the skills listed can be “obtained other ways”…. How? Waiting tables just out of HS? Devaluation of education isn’t the answer. WVU is screwing up here. Of course most of the state is poor, backwards and uneducated so why am I not surprised?

If you read the article it details where the bloated budgets and waste are… the administration… big f@cking surprise there… it’s been the truth for at least 3 decades
 
A bit over the top, Zelda. Making cuts due to programs not
being sustainable could be reasonable. The rest of your
post about these types of programs being "scams"
leading to these institutions "stealing money from the
American public" is nothing more than an opinion with
no proof or evidence.
He embarrasses the University of Pittsburgh with every post he makes
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ski11585
I don’t know. But I’m guessing your imagination will tell you that it was about someone somewhere in West Virginia. But people who don’t need to twist the lyrics of a song to give them a sense of self worth will accept that it had nothing to do with a particular state…but if it did it would have been Maryland.

But congrats to West Virginia for phonetically fitting into the meter of the song. Something for you all to be proud of.
Look, I'm not gonna constantly go back and forth on this. I know they'd hardly been to WVa and some of them not at all. But Danoff changed it from Massachusetts to West Virginia because it sounded better and from then on they began gearing the song towards West Virginia. "Stranger to Blue water" is a perfect example. There are other examples where they began looking for reasons to insert WVa and Danoff cites some examples in the interview from the WVU sight I list below.

The fact is, it's sung about WVa, not about MA, Maryland or Virginia, and we adopted it, so what difference does it make? I mean, everything in that song reeks of the state of West Virginia and how we feel about it. This is a good interview.

 
It’s true that most WVU ardent sports fans are mostly a mix of degenerates and retards.

Not every one though. Probably not even a majority. Certainly not like PSU fans, the great majority of whom should be bulldozed into pits and lit ablaze. And yeah, Ron Cook’s PSU intern assigned to read this site to steal material, that includes you and your boss.

So I’ve put things perfectly into context. Some of their fans are bad. But their university by and large is no worse or better regarded than Pitt. We have to get off the ridiculous high horse many of our delusional alum are on. At my employer, that needs far more STEM grads than Elizabethan Poetry majors, WVU is (sadly) a lot better represented than Pitt grads in the past decade or so. Pitt has lost its way in many of the most important things.
You know, we can have fun and insult our rivals without being a jackass and using slurs.

Be better, loser.
 
Look, I'm not gonna constantly go back and forth on this. I know they'd hardly been to WVa and some of them not at all. But Danoff changed it from Massachusetts to West Virginia because it sounded better and from then on they began gearing the song towards West Virginia. "Stranger to Blue water" is a perfect example. There are other examples where they began looking for reasons to insert WVa and Danoff cites some examples in the interview from the WVU sight I list below.

The fact is, it's sung about WVa, not about MA, Maryland or Virginia, and we adopted it, so what difference does it make? I mean, everything in that song reeks of the state of West Virginia and how we feel about it. This is a good interview.

Sure Jan.
 
I suppose you could teach yourself to be a doctor, too, but you'd have a hard time getting licensed. I know that's a bit hyperbolic but it's not as simple as saying some programs are more worthy of pursuit than others. No matter how much some people want to deny the necessity of these academic fields, we used to believe that understanding our history and humanity was important to growing as a species. Schools like WVU gave the residents of their state an avenue to pursue these degrees at a very high level without leaving and the state was eager to finance the college. I don't know when we convinced ourselves that college should become a purely ,for profit, endeavor but I think it does a disservice to the people who wish to stay home and go to school.

Incidentally, I know someone who studied history at WVU who teaches and just wrote a book. I'm told he is a fantastic teacher.
I agree that everyone should have some exposure to topics like and some should be specialists so they can teach and work in the field. But does there need to be entire departments in every school or can schools using visiting profs to teach fewer classes?

Here's a simple question - if schools were on the hook for student loans for grads that can't afford them, would they offer some of these as degrees?
 
I agree that everyone should have some exposure to topics like and some should be specialists so they can teach and work in the field. But does there need to be entire departments in every school or can schools using visiting profs to teach fewer classes?

Here's a simple question - if schools were on the hook for student loans for grads that can't afford them, would they offer some of these as degrees?
Probably because those departments are typically pretty profitable. Article states it as well. And I can believe that because some of those more popular elective classes are huge. One professor for a hundred students or more at some of the bigger schools. At the end of the day, it's not the professor teaching antiquities that's causing the shortfall. It's the admin above them that are blowing up the budget and that problem really isn't unique to universities, either. It's sort of like blaming a dog's tail for the dog walking into a wall.

Edit: And don't get me wrong, I see where a lot of people question some of these fields of study. I can't completely appreciate the need for some of them either but I also don't know that I'm qualified to have an opinion on whether or not they are justifiable. I have a friend who studied history and I didn't completely "get" their chosen area of focus until she explained it. There were a lot of things I didn't realize or understand and it sort of opened my eyes about the deeper historical context. This wasn't an attempt to advocate for a narrative either. Just factual accounting. I think we hear too much about the dishonest intellectuals and not enough about the ones that let you know when it's just their opinion that is forthcoming.
 
Last edited:
Look, I'm not gonna constantly go back and forth on this. I know they'd hardly been to WVa and some of them not at all. But Danoff changed it from Massachusetts to West Virginia because it sounded better and from then on they began gearing the song towards West Virginia. "Stranger to Blue water" is a perfect example. There are other examples where they began looking for reasons to insert WVa and Danoff cites some examples in the interview from the WVU sight I list below.

The fact is, it's sung about WVa, not about MA, Maryland or Virginia, and we adopted it, so what difference does it make? I mean, everything in that song reeks of the state of West Virginia and how we feel about it. This is a good interview.

it's such a silly and pathetic argument from pitt fans. it really is. Enjoy your song and ignore this.

We have a million things to ridicule wvu about (and vice versa), john denver songs and useless humanities majors arent on that list..
 
  • Haha
Reactions: FireballZ
Probably because those departments are typically pretty profitable. Article states it as well. And I can believe that because some of those more popular elective classes are huge. One professor for a hundred students or more at some of the bigger schools. At the end of the day, it's not the professor teaching antiquities that's causing the shortfall. It's the admin above them that are blowing up the budget and that problem really isn't unique to universities, either. It's sort of like blaming a dog's tail for the dog walking into a wall.

Edit: And don't get me wrong, I see where a lot of people question some of these fields of study. I can't completely appreciate the need for some of them either but I also don't know that I'm qualified to have an opinion on whether or not they are justifiable. I have a friend who studied history and I didn't completely "get" their chosen area of focus until she explained it. There were a lot of things I didn't realize or understand and it sort of opened my eyes about the deeper historical context. This wasn't an attempt to advocate for a narrative either. Just factual accounting. I think we hear too much about the dishonest intellectuals and not enough about the ones that let you know when it's just their opinion that is forthcoming.
I agree that admin costs are the biggest driver. But you really shied away from my question. The departments they are cutting are those typically associated with low-income jobs for grads with those degrees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shomeydamonee
I agree that admin costs are the biggest driver. But you really shied away from my question. The departments they are cutting are those typically associated with low-income jobs for grads with those degrees.
I don't think any business ever avoided a profit center just because the consumer's outcomes were typically poor. There are actually entire business models that depend on ignoring consumer outcomes.
 
I don't think any business ever avoided a profit center just because the consumer's outcomes were typically poor. There are actually entire business models that depend on ignoring consumer outcomes.
Again, you shied away from the question - which included the condition that schools pay for loans from which they benefited.

Also, I'm not sold that that these departments are "profitable".
 
Edit: And don't get me wrong, I see where a lot of people question some of these fields of study. I can't completely appreciate the need for some of them either but I also don't know that I'm qualified to have an opinion on whether or not they are justifiable.
Just as none of us, including the author of the hit piece, aren’t qualified to speak to the inner details of WVU’s budget, and how they will best see their way out of their financial predicament.
 
Again, you shied away from the question - which included the condition that schools pay for loans from which they benefited.

Also, I'm not sold that that these departments are "profitable".
Just not sure how to answer your question because the question doesn't make sense in any context. Just about every loan for just about anything you can purchase negates profits. Student loans, with the way they're constructed, would make every course of study a bad bet if the school had to pay for it. But that is all pretty far from the point.

And even if you're correct and these departments aren't profitable, it's not like businesses run everything at a profit either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: singregardless
I think a big part of the challenge is that more students are attending college who are less smart. In the past, smarter students dedicating themselves to degrees like Philosophy and creative writing could go on to get an advanced degree or could simply get a decent job having a college degree. Now, a student with a philosophy or gender studies degree who also isn't above average intelligence isn't going to be highly sought after in the job market.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shomeydamonee
I think many schools should shed dead end degrees and only have majors kids can get jobs in. I’d never go to school to study philosophy, and I loved my philosophy classes at Pitt. Kids go to college to get degrees that translate into jobs. Along the way, many get sidetracked into dead end majors. I’d like to see that dead weight cut.
 
Just as none of us, including the author of the hit piece, aren’t qualified to speak to the inner details of WVU’s budget, and how they will best see their way out of their financial predicament.
Not sure about the author's qualifications but WVU is a public university so their financial information would be available for scrutiny and he did outline what got WVU into this predicament. Just for the sake of comparison, IUP is pretty much in the same boat having spent money to build up housing and other services to facilitate grown, only to see admissions go down.

Perhaps if we were reading that they were still going to offer those programs but in a different way, it would make sense to do cuts. Like partnering with another university or something.
 
I think many schools should shed dead end degrees and only have majors kids can get jobs in. I’d never go to school to study philosophy, and I loved my philosophy classes at Pitt. Kids go to college to get degrees that translate into jobs. Along the way, many get sidetracked into dead end majors. I’d like to see that dead weight cut.
But like... you can get plenty of jobs studying what you're probably classifying as dead end degrees.

What's our metric here for good jobs? $50K? $75K? $100K? $300K?

Someone can major in the humanities, whether that's history, WSGS, philosophy, English, etc., and be making $100K by the time they're ten years out from graduation.
 
I think many schools should shed dead end degrees and only have majors kids can get jobs in. I’d never go to school to study philosophy, and I loved my philosophy classes at Pitt. Kids go to college to get degrees that translate into jobs. Along the way, many get sidetracked into dead end majors. I’d like to see that dead weight cut.
State schools, absolutely right. There are plenty of foo foo schools for those who want to flit about and party for five years, to get their “Mrs” degrees, and/or to be indoctrinated in the fringe left or fringe right politics. State schools should certainly offer some humanities, Lit, Art History, Music History, etc for the ‘well rounding’ aspect but concentrate on STEM, because that’s what our country and particularly a state like Wv desperately need.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fk_Pitt
Not sure about the author's qualifications but WVU is a public university so their financial information would be available for scrutiny and he did outline what got WVU into this predicament. Just for the sake of comparison, IUP is pretty much in the same boat having spent money to build up housing and other services to facilitate grown, only to see admissions go down.

Perhaps if we were reading that they were still going to offer those programs but in a different way, it would make sense to do cuts. Like partnering with another university or something.
I guess my point is that they have a plan and are doing what they think is the best way out of it. One can look at financials but that doesn’t tell the whole tale. And sadly there are always going to be victims in these situations and someone is going to be unhappy.

Just like in business. Disney recently cut 7000 employees. Closed down a major hotel attraction a year after it opened. Laid off TV personalities. Cut their visual effects team including the senior VP. Someone is going to bear the brunt of these things. There are several ways to skin a cat or in this case trim the fat. People want to rip WVU because ideologically their cut’s impact the departments that they support. But mistakes get made and cuts need to be made. I’m sure these were tough decisions. But I suppose it’s fun for some to rip them for them.
 
I guess my point is that they have a plan and are doing what they think is the best way out of it. One can look at financials but that doesn’t tell the whole tale. And sadly there are always going to be victims in these situations and someone is going to be unhappy.

Just like in business. Disney recently cut 7000 employees. Closed down a major hotel attraction a year after it opened. Laid off TV personalities. Cut their visual effects team including the senior VP. Someone is going to bear the brunt of these things. There are several ways to skin a cat or in this case trim the fat. People want to rip WVU because ideologically their cut’s impact the departments that they support. But mistakes get made and cuts need to be made. I’m sure these were tough decisions. But I suppose it’s fun for some to rip them for them.
And I'm not going to disagree with that part of it other than Disney's mission is very different than a public university. It's also likely that the risk in making those moves are quite different as well.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT