It is not just one group of Running Backs from Penn State or Pitt to assess the coming Game. It is also, about strengths and weakness on both Team's Coaches, Game Plans, Players Unit Execution, and some unknowns in just being the Second Game?
Unit Analysis by player's talent, experience and previous year coaching. Penn State will have a stronger Defense with more 2 of 3 Units experience at Linebackers and Secondary to defend against Pitt Running Backs and unknown Pitt Wideouts that won't have Tyler Boyd and will have a New Pitt OC in Canada that may require some adjustments.
On The Pitt positive sides is that Pitt's QB is far more experience and fits in with Pitt's New OC but also Pitt's Offensive Line is far more experience and more powerful to take on Penn State's New Defensive Line as well as open up holes for Pitt's great Running Backs and that should favor Pitt in the second game.
At the same time, Penn State Defensive Line will be having to form a New Defensive Line to stop those Pitt Running Backs, pressure and sack Pitt's QB is unknown. How the Pitt Wideouts do will also be unknown until Game Day but Villanova and Kent State games will give some hints. Penn State also may have challenges on the Special Teams compared to Pitt having advantage just based on seeing last years performances?
Unit By Unit Analysis For Pitt-Penn State Game:
Coaching Favors Pitt:
Coaching for once in a long time favors Pitt that has them all back except for the OC. Penn State Coaching Staff will be adjusting to 3 New Coaches in OC's Moorhead, OLC Limegrover, and DBC Banks on top of LBC Pry going to DC for Penn State Defense.
I. COACHING:
Favors Pitt Since Less New Coaches
Sideline Coaching Favors Pitt Just Better As Seen Last Year
Have Time Adjustments Favors Pitt: Just Better As Seen Last Year
New OC's Even Both New But Pitt OC Has Worked With Narduzzi
Coaching Synopsis: PITT
Pitt Head Coach Narduzzi has worked with OC Canada previously than Penn State Head Coach Franklin has worked with OC Moorhead. New OLC Limegrover taking over the PSU OL will have to adjust too, more than Pitt OLC in his second year with a more experience OL. Penn State New DC Pry also has to adjust along with incorporating a New DBC in Banks. In addition, Pitt's Pat & Staff are known for bold risk taking that worked last year late in the games on Iowa, GT, and Cuse games. Pitt players even when behind in Iowa, UNC, Miami, and ND losses came back and almost won 3 of those games? Only Navy beat Pitt from First Quarter to Last showing Pitt was unprepared both coaching and execution by the end of first Quarter and entire game. Compared to Coach Franklin & Staff that was often beaten by Half-Time or shortly into the Third Quarter in Temple, Michigan, OSU, and blown away by MSU. Penn State gave Georgia a good game even losing Hack Attack as McSorley did very well which should be remembered by Pitt coaches this year. However, Georgia was coached by a Staff almost gone and still won with ease?
II. OFFENSE:
Offensive Units Favor Pitt
Quarterback Favors Pitt More Experience But New OC
Offensive Line Favors Pitt Played Together More Experience
Running Backs Even Both Very Good To Great But Pitt OL Better
Wideouts Favors Penn State Talent, Speed & Experience
Tight End Favors Pitt Block, Catch & Run After Catch
Offensive Synopsis: PITT
Although Talent favors Penn State the experience Pitt has together with all positions except Wideouts along with Stable Staff of Coaches give Pitt an edge here. Especially, with Pitt OL versus PSU DL. Still, Penn state is putting in a whole new Moorhead's Offensive System with a New Inexperience QB with questions on OL? Yet, PSU Linebackers and Secondary are more experienced but with 2 Coaches assuming new positions meaning they will have to adjust while learning together with players on execution?
III. DEFENSE:
Defensive Units Favor Penn State
Defensive Line Favors Pitt As PSU Has Some New Players & Pitt OL Vets
Linebackers Favors PSU Bigger, Faster, Cover & Tackle More Experience
Secondary Favors PSU All DBs Back With Experience But New DBC
Defensive Synopsis: PENN STATE
Although Pitt may have an edge of its OL versus Penn State's DL. Penn State has true advantages at Linebackers and Secondary experience, talent, speed, and could be tougher for Pitt QB, OL, and Running Backs without knowing how Pitt Wideouts will be doing by the second game. Penn State has more talent and experience to execute the Defense Coaching favors Pitt since new coaching players adjustments needed? If Penn State does come up with a Defensive Line it will be tougher on Pitt Offense unless they do have Wideouts that come through way more than expected in the second game?
IV. SPECIAL TEAMS
Favors PITT
Punting Unit Should Favor Pitt Coverages:
Punt Running Back could favor Penn State depends on Roster Choices
Kickoffs Should Be Even
Kick Off should favor Pitt Coverages but PSU has RB Talent
Field Goals should favor Pitt until PSU improves from last year
Special Teams Synopsis: PITT
This is a tougher Unit to compare and gauge until we know the final roster. Pitt Coaching was better on Special Teams than Penn State last year. Pitt was able to Block Punts, Fake Punts that made 1st downs, and kept Drives alive. Pitt has far better consistent Field Goal Kicking and Pitt's Special Teams Coach is just flat out better than Penn State and one of the best in College Football. I suspect Whitehead and Ffrench should be a tad better due to better Special Teams Coaching, but Penn State has loads of talent with speed for Special Teams?
Big Unknowns Analysis:
Both New OC?
Rosters Not Finalized??
Only the Second Game???
Weather Should Be Great????
Refs Tight or Loose Game Calls?????
Home Field Advantage Should Be Even??????
Could Be More Fights In The Stands Among Fans If One Teams Gets Big Lead???????
Previous Pitt-Penn State Football Series Era Comparison Today:
Usually Penn State's Paterno Era Non-Compliance Many Pitt Heatbreak Losses!
Today, Pitt's Pat Narduzzi Era Does Not Care What Happen Yesterday Just Today!
Current Prediction Analysis:
PITT Wins By 3 In Late Kick In High Scoring Game!
Or
PENN STATE Wins By 3 In A Low Scoring Game!!