Oklahoma State attendance at Heinz (ranked #9): 38,952
Villanova attendance at Heinz: 50,149.
People come out when there is hope. Which there isn't much of lately. And even then, just barely. Even in the legendary Cinci vs. Pitt showdown for the Big East championship you had to have the stars align for it to be both the last game of the year AND at home AND between the top two teams in the conference AND that it wasn't followed by a neutral site conference championship game like the ACC is.
There is no evidence our fans show up more to see better teams. The exceptions we can all agree on are the big three historic rivals. UCF will not draw well next year even if they're ranked #2 in the country like Miami was last year.
Let me Start by saying... C’mon... you know darn well the Villanova and Oklahoma St attendance comparison you pointed out is missing some key information:
The Villanova game was the first game of the 2016 season. A season with the most talented players Pitt has had in at least the past 5 years. We’re talking Conner, Price, Boyd, Orndoff, Boyd, Q. Henderson, Peterson... and so on.
The attendance at that game had nothing to do with who the opponent was and everything to do with the notion of a “New hope” at the beginning of a season that looks even more promising due to the amount of talent on the team. You mean to tell me that if Ok St was in place of Villanova for the first game of that season, there would have be less fans. Please. The stadium might actually have been filled to capacity.
Again - A new season + good players = Anything is possible.
Now let’s move to the Oklahoma State game.
Pitt had almost lost to a lame Youngstown State team in the first game of that 2018 season. Pitt looked pretty bad if you recall. Then, they embarrassed the fans with that pathetic performance against PSU in the next game. After that game, there was not a Pitt fan alive who thought Pitt had a chance of keeping it within a 4 TD game against a very good Oklahoma State team- And, not surprisingly, the Pitt fans were all proven to be right.
Pitt fans (again nothing new here) are at a point now where they have witnessed so many piles of crap on game day for so many years that they can smell another steaming pile of it coming a mile away ... and will do anything to avoid it.
But my point isn’t even about which opponents would attract more fans right now.
My point is about Pitt keeping the kind of schedule that is more attractive on paper now and one that would be more exciting for Pitt fans to watch live when Pitt one day finally puts together a truly competitive team... and ultimately a schedule that would allow a very talented and well coached Pitt team to control its own destiny.