ADVERTISEMENT

OT: Antonio Brown

I don’t think it is a black and white issue, but I do agree with you about Ben

Not exonerating Brown, but Roethlisberger and Tomlin are part of the problem as well and have been for years... In the case of Tomlin, it’s not his game coaching I’m referring to. His relationship with Roethlisberger is the problem. That is part of Brown’s beef. Some points on the subject:
  1. Roethlisberger is Tomlin’s boy. He can do no wrong. Whatever Big Ben wants, he gets. Whether that’s drafting a player, or firing a coach, or signing a free agent.not completely true as the steelers drafted a QB early in the third and ben obviously didn't want it. But its pretty typical of a coach to baby the starting QB. Its the most important position in sports.
  2. Cowher was a players coach, with no favoritism. He let Joey Porter tear Big Ben a new one in front of his teammates in the locker room for his lack of leadership. Cowher did not interfere. It was a message to Ben and everyone else that they were a team.
  3. It didn’t do any good. Roethlisberger lacks real leadership in times of strife and chaos. They only ones that have been leaders recently are DeCastro and Heyward.
  4. Roethlisberger is every bit a prima donna as Brown. He shows up a couple of days for off season workouts and then takes the rest of the time off to go on a family vacation. When Brown saw that, he followed suit... He couldn’t have scheduled it around the workouts???agree ben should stay for the whole offseason workouts, not so much for the work but to be a leader. But this isn't about offseason workouts no one really cared that brown left either. Ben did, by all accounts show up for all practices and walk throughs, Brown missed those the week before cleveland and missed one before the saints game.
  5. Roethlisberger’s lack of leadership showed up again when he calls players out on the radio and then refuses to say the Brown is the number one receiver on the team. He feels he’s “earned” the right to call out players. Yes, but not on the radio! Do it in the locker room in front of the player. You’ll get more respect.agree.
Bottom line is Ben isn't the leader you hope your QB would be and neither is tomlin to be honest. but they aren't getting rid of ben or tomlin in the offseason. If Brown can't deal with that they have to move him even though chances are they won't be as good after the trade, multiple reports have said Brown got all pissy after JuJu got team mvp. I didn't hear anything about Ben throwing a fit about it.
 
It would be a lot easier to replace AB than it will be to replace Ben or Tomlin .

A 30 yr old (31 in July ] is not young for WR .

If you can get a quality defensive player and a high draft pick I’d say don’t let the door hit you in the ass on your way out AB .

I’m not saying that AB isn’t a great player , but sometimes enough is enough . But only if you get value in return do I cut him loose .

AB has shown childish behavior a zillion times on the sidelines , think it’s not getting old for his teammates !

It appears that Ben has matured and learned from his boorish behavior of his youth not so for AB .

Haley seems to rub a lot of people the wrong way , not just Ben .

The pays pretty good , but thinking coaching a bunch of young rich , egotistical , famous twenty ( in this case thirty ) somethings is easy I think your not thinking clearly .
 
AB isn't all that easy to just trade and receive a lot in return.
To trade him, that contract goes with him. At 31(when season starts) and owed 65+ million, with that attitude. Yes on the field he's talented, but factor in the 3 things mentioned. 50% of the teams are going to be out.

Those still in at best may give a 1st round pick if it's a late 1st. No one will give us a top 5/10 pick.
Personally I'm thinking a 2nd & conditional 4th.

I heard an interview with Bill Polian on Thursday. He said Steelers wouldn't get that much either.

An interesting time for the Steelers for sure.
 
The fire was ignited by Ben. Ben should apologize to AB and move on
I loathe Rottenberger.....but AB is a jackass. I'd dump him in the worst possible way. And if Harrison makes Canton, I wouldn't send anyone from the Steelers.
 
The Vikings went 13-3 last year and the second round of the playoffs.
Went 8-7-1 with cousins and are likewise watching from the couch.

Not the best example to use
Like I said, it's a RISK, personally I'd rather have big balls and roll dice rather than play it safe. So I fully accept the result if it blows up in my face, I'd rather do that than roll with a Kordell Stewart for 7 years.
 
AB isn't all that easy to just trade and receive a lot in return.
To trade him, that contract goes with him. At 31(when season starts) and owed 65+ million, with that attitude. Yes on the field he's talented, but factor in the 3 things mentioned. 50% of the teams are going to be out.

Those still in at best may give a 1st round pick if it's a late 1st. No one will give us a top 5/10 pick.
Personally I'm thinking a 2nd & conditional 4th.

I heard an interview with Bill Polian on Thursday. He said Steelers wouldn't get that much either.

An interesting time for the Steelers for sure.


Agree with this, think they will be fortunate to get a 1st rounder for him. Dallas gave up a #1 for Amari Cooper, but he’s almost 7 years younger and still working on his rookie deal.
 
Like I said, it's a RISK, personally I'd rather have big balls and roll dice rather than play it safe. So I fully accept the result if it blows up in my face, I'd rather do that than roll with a Kordell Stewart for 7 years.
Kordell was way more successful than cousins.

Kordell appeared in 9 playoff games with a 5-4 record.

Cousins has made 2 thus far with an 0-2 record
 
NOBODY, is totally perfect, I'd argue he didn't lose those games. It's funny fans like you watching on TV pissed he didn't "drag a foot" as if it's easy to do.

I didn’t question its ease or difficulty. The argument was that Brown never lost a game for the Steelers and I gave two examples of potential counter arguments.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BuffetParrothead
I'm thinking a 1st and a 3rd for Brown will be the return. Or a young player instead of the 3rd. I read Raiders 1 + Carl Joseph. I'd do that in a heartbeat.

Cooper = 1st
Cooks = 1st 2 times
Watkins = 6th and a young starting cb
Benjamin = 3rd and a 7th
 
Never had any personal dealings with Roethlisberger, know multiple casino employees who did however.

One was a bartender at the Venetian, Roethlisberger had ordered a soda and requested it come in a bottle, not from the soda gun. Somehow this got confused and he got a “draft” soda, which he preceded to throw across the room while cursing out everyone involved. Also know a security guard at the Wynn who said he was one of the worst aholes he ever deal with, on par with Jerry Seinfeld.

This was all over a decade ago, since he got married and started a family Roethlisberger seems like a different person from what you see reported. Maybe he just grew up.
Just saw a tweet from Chris Paul, stating “it doesn’t cost anything to be a good person”.

Why don’t people understand this?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigBird80 and BFo8
I loathe Rottenberger.....but AB is a jackass. I'd dump him in the worst possible way. And if Harrison makes Canton, I wouldn't send anyone from the Steelers.
They welcomed Harrison on the field with the likes of Mean Joe Greene in the ceremony at the Patriots game just 3 weeks ago.

This is show business now, not old style football. Art SR and Dan are dead. Most of the players are divas. It sells. Not your pappy's Steelers.
 


His focus is now on Peter King. I thought Bell's popularity in Pittsburgh fell off a cliff. That may not even compare to the free fall that Brown is taking right now.
 
They welcomed Harrison on the field with the likes of Mean Joe Greene in the ceremony at the Patriots game just 3 weeks ago.

This is show business now, not old style football. Art SR and Dan are dead. Most of the players are divas. It sells. Not your pappy's Steelers.
You keep saying this doesn’t make it true. Steeler ownership does not look favorably upon th diva show business. They just don’t. Playoff wins, preferably home paydays in the playoffs, are the stated goals and what matters.

If they keep AB and resign Lev bell, then you’re on to something.
 


His focus is now on Peter King. I thought Bell's popularity in Pittsburgh fell off a cliff. That may not even compare to the free fall that Brown is taking right now.

Again, this shows that AB is a selfish sob. He's more worried about the "power" that an all-pro voter like Peter King has, and less about owning up to his contractual agreement to the Steelers organization and his teamates.

I wonder how many games Mike Evans is going to sit out and pout over. My guess is 0.
 
Kordell was way more successful than cousins.

Kordell appeared in 9 playoff games with a 5-4 record.

Cousins has made 2 thus far with an 0-2 record
Cousins hasn't had a chance yet. And I'd rather take a chance with a guy that can throw.

As for Kordell, unlike Ben who carries the whole team, that would probably go 6-10 every year without him, Kordell was carried by the defense and Bettis. and Bettis could never win a ring, until Ben carried him there.
 
Cousins hasn't had a chance yet. And I'd rather take a chance with a guy that can throw.

As for Kordell, unlike Ben who carries the whole team, that would probably go 6-10 every year without him, Kordell was carried by the defense and Bettis. and Bettis could never win a ring, until Ben carried him there.
Kirk cousins is a very interesting hill to die on
 
  • Like
Reactions: lilspainishflea
The Pittsburgh media, outside of Madden and Cook have been critical of Ben for years. He’s a jerk, everyone knows it, and probably was a spark that lit AB’s fire.

But give me a break. Both Ben and AB got passed over for team MVP. Only AB crossed the line since. He walked out on his team 3 times this year alone.

Bringing race into it is stupid. The media you’re questioning has been defending Tomlin for 10 years.
Players know JAs when they see them...
 
Kirk cousins is a very interesting hill to die on
Who's dying, he still has several years to play, look at Philip Rivers, he's done nothing either, but still going, it's not out of the question that Cousins can succeed down the road.
 
Cousins hasn't had a chance yet. And I'd rather take a chance with a guy that can throw.

As for Kordell, unlike Ben who carries the whole team, that would probably go 6-10 every year without him, Kordell was carried by the defense and Bettis. and Bettis could never win a ring, until Ben carried him there.

Cousins is terrible.
 
Sober up.

If the Stillers over pay for a mediocre qb like cousins -they’ll be in trouble
I just want them to PAY for a QB, whether it be with a top draft pick or money, rather than go cheap with some mediocre 3rd round pick or 5th rounder.
 
since Pittsburgh is extending Big Ben I don't think signing a free agent qb is even on their mind
 
Who's dying, he still has several years to play, look at Philip Rivers, he's done nothing either, but still going, it's not out of the question that Cousins can succeed down the road.

Rivers wasn’t a late bloomer. He’s been very good his entire career. And while neither Cousins nor Rivers have won anything it’s still an absurd comparison. Rivers has a shot at the HOF despite never winning. Cousins is just ok. He’s been around long enough that he is what he is. There’s not gonna be any kind of great leap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lilspainishflea
Who's dying, he still has several years to play, look at Philip Rivers, he's done nothing either, but still going, it's not out of the question that Cousins can succeed down the road.

Rivers is a lock for the HOF, almost no way Cousins gets there.
 
Rivers wasn’t a late bloomer. He’s been very good his entire career. And while neither Cousins nor Rivers have won anything it’s still an absurd comparison. Rivers has a shot at the HOF despite never winning. Cousins is just ok. He’s been around long enough that he is what he is. There’s not gonna be any kind of great leap.

No Cousins career wasn't much different than Rivers, they both sat a year or two, then became starters. Not absurd at all, you can stack up the seasons Cousins has started up against Rivers and they are just as good or better, it's absurd to say otherwise.

I guess 4298 yards 70% completions, 30 TDs 10 INTS is "just ok".
 
No Cousins career wasn't much different than Rivers, they both sat a year or two, then became starters. Not absurd at all, you can stack up the seasons Cousins has started up against Rivers and they are just as good or better, it's absurd to say otherwise.

I guess 4298 yards 70% completions, 30 TDs 10 INTS is "just ok".

Yes. He’s just ok. And was ranked 15th this year. Rivers was 4th.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/viking...ranks-kirk-cousins-in-middle-of-the-pack/amp/
 
  • Like
Reactions: lilspainishflea
Did I see that Antonio Brown had time to appear on the new singing/dancing/vaudeville show The Mask, or something like that, on Fox?
 
You keep saying this doesn’t make it true. Steeler ownership does not look favorably upon th diva show business. They just don’t. Playoff wins, preferably home paydays in the playoffs, are the stated goals and what matters.

If they keep AB and resign Lev bell, then you’re on to something.
Bell decision was already made and was a money thing. Totally money. Even though Bell had committed stupid pothead antics for years, they didn't abandon him until it became a money thing. Because running backs are easy commodities to find cheap.

Brown is a more premium position player so we'll indeed see how they tolerate all this. My bet is a lot more than with Bell.
 
AB isn't all that easy to just trade and receive a lot in return.
To trade him, that contract goes with him. At 31(when season starts) and owed 65+ million, with that attitude. Yes on the field he's talented, but factor in the 3 things mentioned. 50% of the teams are going to be out.

Those still in at best may give a 1st round pick if it's a late 1st. No one will give us a top 5/10 pick.
Personally I'm thinking a 2nd & conditional 4th.

I heard an interview with Bill Polian on Thursday. He said Steelers wouldn't get that much either.

An interesting time for the Steelers for sure.
Incorrect the contract that goes with him is 3 years and 44 million the other 21 million is bonuses that go against the Steelers cap. AB is actually a pretty good bargain for the new team which is why they shouldn't take anything less than a mid round one and mid round third
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zeldas Open Roof
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT