As someone who has spent a lot of time in both cities, and who still has many close friends in both places, I definitely view it as a rivalry and I can absolutely tell you they view it as a blood feud.
They want to shove it so far up our asses they can taste it. If you don’t think it’s a rivalry now, you soon will look at it as a rivalry — I guarantee it!
There are many similarities between the cultures of Pittsburgh and Cleveland. That much is definitely true. However, one glaring difference between the two is that Cleveland is delusionally optimistic regarding their sports teams and Pittsburgh is unrelentingly pessimistic regarding their sports teams.
For example, a few years ago - probably several years ago now - Pitt played at Notre Dame and as we drove home the next day from South Bend, the Steelers were edging the Browns in a very good game. I want to say Pittsburgh won, 20-17 or something like that.
Well, we listened to the game on the Cleveland Browns radio network and I am telling you even though they lost, there were 25 straight calls to their postgame show just bragging about the team. “This aspect of the team is great!...that dude is incredible, etc.”. It was basically an hour and a half of, “Yes we lost today but we are going to be incredible in the next few years.”
It was really surreal to hear after a loss. Also, it wasn’t just the fans – it was the hosts as well. It was flat out open cheerleading. I don’t care how you feel about the Pittsburgh media, nobody does anything here remotely like what you regularly hear in Cleveland.
Then, we got into Pittsburgh airspace and listened to caller after caller after caller bitching and moaning about every aspect of the Steelers team.
It was a whole bunch of, “If they think they’re going to get away with this next week against Miami (or whomever), they’re kidding themselves. This team is overrated and it stinks.”
It was a lot of stuff like that.
To me, that’s the real difference and it is also why I am exactly 0% surprised that they are acting like maniacs right now and planning their Super Bowl parades (plural) because they finally drafted a good quarterback and traded for a good receiver.
You watch, Pittsburgh will go 11-5 and Cleveland will go 9-7, and the Pittsburgh fans will treat their season as a disaster while the Cleveland fans will anoint their season as the next step in their inevitable march to immortality.
I guarantee that’s how this is going to go down if the season plays out the way I think it probably will.