No... it really isnt debatable.
You are losing, in the 4th quarter. You have a horrible offense and a great defense. 100 out of 100 times you kick the fg.
What possible reason would you have trying to get 2.5 yards on 4th down there??? Furthermore, we still woulda lost. So what is the point?
Uh they were at the one yard line. There are a lot of coaches who would have gone for it. Some have been successful and been praised for being aggressive. Some have not made it and have been criticized. It’s the nature of the game
Again it’s a very debatable call. Taking the stance on either side is pig headed