DT I don't remember now but gotta ask, you are usually an optimistic person on here. Were you at all excited about Stallings coming to Pitt or were you open that it could work? Just curious.
Here's the longer answer.
I remember the Saturday before the Stallings was announced when I was texting with someone with very close knowledge of the search. I remember his text -- "it's looking like Stallings." I also remember my reply. "please not Stallings." I actually called him right after to ask specifically who he was talking to know if his reports were credible (even though I already knew).
So after Stallings was announced, I too had serious questions about the associations with Barnes and the Turner search firm. A couple of theories have been suggested in this thread and it's hard not to believe that there's not at least a little truth to some of them.
But beyond that problem, my immediate issue was it was hard for me to see, on paper, how Stallings could have been any kind of an equal of Dixon, let alone an upgrade. Plenty of this opinion came from the notion that I thought highly of Dixon. But I also know plenty of fans who were more than happy to see Dixon gone who felt much the same way.
Still, once we the information all settled in, I soon came to the conclusion that regardless if Stallings wasn't an upgrade either, he wasn't a hack. He was an experienced coach so we might as well see what he can do. But where I first started having some issues was with his recruiting in the first seven months. There was a lot of big talk (which is not unusual for any coach) but not much as far as results.
One example was Kamari Lawrence. The staff kept talking to folks saying they were really confident they would get him. Someone told me of a conversation they had with one of his staff saying they were sure they were get Lawrence and the very next day Lawrence trimmed his final list from 4 to 3 eliminating Pitt.
Still going into the season, I continued to keep an open mind. And I was pretty enthused when we beat Virginia. But of course, as the season when on, it became clear to me that he was indeed the wrong guy at the wrong time. And then 0-18 happened ...