I think I was the lone voice on this board that disagreed with the Reilly Smith trade. I didn't like giving up draft picks for 30+ year old players. I was told a 3rd round pick was nothing for a proven forward that would add some jam to the lineup. Turned out to be more like jelly. Jake Guentzel, Kris Letang, and even Smith were past 3rd round picks. Sometimes you get lucky. The Pens need all the draft capital they can get at this point. Giving some away for 30+ year old players that most likely wouldn't make the Pens serious SC contenders just didn't make sense to me.
I stayed quiet with the Karlsson deal even though I didn't like that deal either. Too much money and a 1st round pick. The deal made a little sense in that Dubas was able to get rid of some dead weight and salary cap, even though most people that know hockey knew that Karlsson was long on offense and short on defense. I put little weight toward regular season major awards. Especially the Norris Trophy.
Now the franchise sits at a crossroads. Saddled with an old team and crippling contracts, very little future prospects, and a head coach that refuses to change with the tide. Thankful for the Cup runs, but lean times look ahead. Dubas has some work to do.