ADVERTISEMENT

Pickens ain’t optimistic!

plenty of people to point out within this organization, he's just one of many who are deservedly getting their fair share of blame.
Absolutely but each year the organization chooses one person, usually a player, to pin the blame on. Leaks start filtering out soon after each disappointing finish.
 
Right about now soufie is thinking about how to craft his next post defending George, saying it’s not a big deal, it’s manufactured outrage and George still caught 3 balls for 50 yards so there’s nothing to see here. Plus, being on time is an outdated practice foisted on society by colonizers from Europe.
well i think we can agree that if he miraculously would grow up, play hard, show up on time, not have tantrums, not give up on plays, not sulk on the sidelines when things arent great, then yes, you just ride it out and let him finish his last year here in pittsburgh under his rookie contract.

The problem is, he cant, he wont so that's where i believe we disagree with the few pickens supporters. both sides are better off without each other, we just have to figure out how to "profit" somehow..
 
  • Love
Reactions: Fk_Pitt
Serious question. Has Mike Tomlin ever “reached” a head case like Pickens? As someone else said he and the team tolerated AB because he was an elite receiver and he really didn’t go off the reservation till the end of the AB may be the only example MT was able to control a bit
Claypool, DJ ... being reported GP was late to the playoff game, and a staff member saying that was him being him.
 
Pickens is literally the only receiving threat this team has which puts him in an almost unwinnable situation. His current salary is also very team friendly right now. That being said he is going to demand to be paid as an elite #1 receiver and I’m not sure he’s worth that. He may be more of a top end #2 than a #1, add in that he can be a distraction as well and I don’t think you can break the bank for him unless you have no other choice.
He could help himself and his team out a lot if he:
  1. Gave 100% effort on every snap;
  2. learned to run a pass route;
  3. participated in blocking;
  4. stopped running his mouth, tangling with opposing DBs and drawing personal fouls;
  5. developed some level of consistency at his job.
He's a guy that has a lot of talent but just as many flaws. He's the best receiver the Stillers have, which is a big reason why their offense sucks.
 
He could help himself and his team out a lot if he:
  1. Gave 100% effort on every snap;
  2. learned to run a pass route;
  3. participated in blocking;
  4. stopped running his mouth, tangling with opposing DBs and drawing personal fouls;
  5. developed some level of consistency at his job.
He's a guy that has a lot of talent but just as many flaws. He's the best receiver the Stillers have, which is a big reason why their offense sucks.
that's what is frustrating about him, he has the talent. these guys just sabotage their career with this toxic, pitiful efforts and if only they just toned it down and did just the basics, he'd have a good career.

just look at dionte johnson, guy just wont shut up. he could have been a top 10 wr in this league and now he's on his 4th team and looking for a job..
 
Pickens reminds me of Randy Moss before he went to New England for a few years.
Moss was a generational talent at WR and it showed every single time he stepped onto the field. Nobody has ever/will ever say that about Pickens. Statistically and results-wise, through their first 3 seasons of NFL football, they aren't in the same universe.
 
Moss was a generational talent at WR and it showed every single time he stepped onto the field. Nobody has ever/will ever say that about Pickens. Statistically and results-wise, through their first 3 seasons of NFL football, they aren't in the same universe.
Moss was also a problem child before he went to NE. That was the point, well, and it was partly a joke because Pickens hasn't shown that level of talent. But Moss was on his way to being a castoff like Dionte has become and his career was resurrected because he moved to a locker room that wasn't about the nonsense. They didn't have guys that would put up with it and nobody revered the coach for being a "player's coach", aka, pushover.
 
that's what is frustrating about him, he has the talent. these guys just sabotage their career with this toxic, pitiful efforts and if only they just toned it down and did just the basics, he'd have a good career.

just look at dionte johnson, guy just wont shut up. he could have been a top 10 wr in this league and now he's on his 4th team and looking for a job..
Jameson Williams for his first two years with the Lions was a similar head case, got into lots of trouble off the field, didn't "get it" on the field. Couldn't run a route, didn't block, wasn't putting in the work, etc. They basically benched him for 2 years using him only for a couple plays per game. Dan Campbell and staff stayed patient with him, worked on him and now he is a major weapon for the best offense in the NFL. Of course Williams is much faster and is a better athlete than Pickens.

I don't know who got through to him or what caused the light to come on for Jamo, but I truly believe that the culture that the Lions have built rescued him from being one of those guys who was facing the very real likelihood of being a total bust and out of a job in 3-4 years.
 
Can’t say he’s very productive. Mildly productive yes, when he wants to be. He’s Farmer Ted-king of the dipshits. Someone in that WR room has to catch balls and by default it’s him. He’s a one trick pony with behavioral issues. He’s just not a WR1 and is going to want paid like one. Who would pay a malcontent with only one skill set 25-30 million? That just means more drama next year—maybe more than this year if it’s possible. No doubt the Steelers are having conversations internally about shopping him around the league. Maybe another team will want the headache at his price for a year.

I’d shop him and essentially every player not named Boswell around the league. Sign Fields to a cheap deal and get lots of draft picks.

Thank God Cowher had a couple 6-10 seasons. Without them there would have been no super bowls. Hopefully the Steelers aren’t fixated on stumbling to another 9-8 record and some weird manufactured non losing season streak. Bite the bullet and try reloading. This is the way.
Leading receiver the last two seasons , of course he’s productive and far more
Than his salary.

Again - who is being emotional about this , again ?
 
If we see Dulac refute it, you know it’s the Steelers giving him the marching orders and doing damage control in an effort to keep his trade value from sliding.
They aren’t going to trade him

My prediction
$1.6 mil is dirt cheap for a wr
 
Jameson Williams for his first two years with the Lions was a similar head case, got into lots of trouble off the field, didn't "get it" on the field. Couldn't run a route, didn't block, wasn't putting in the work, etc. They basically benched him for 2 years using him only for a couple plays per game. Dan Campbell and staff stayed patient with him, worked on him and now he is a major weapon for the best offense in the NFL. Of course Williams is much faster and is a better athlete than Pickens.

I don't know who got through to him or what caused the light to come on for Jamo, but I truly believe that the culture that the Lions have built rescued him from being one of those guys who was facing the very real likelihood of being a total bust and out of a job in 3-4 years.
yeah, unfortunately the steelers locker room culture seems to be more enabling such behaviors in the last decade than it is "Fixing" it.

15-20 years ago, steelers culture was an asset, now? pretty much a liability and major cause of our lack of success..
 
Yep
It’s sop for local sports media
They hated a total effort guy like juju as well .

Should ask why TJ had zero tackles for a few games in a row ?
They won't go after TJ. He's been deemed a superstar talent just like the superstar coach. Everyone is willing to admit he's underperformed but there's always a reason. TJ gets a pass because the coverage isn't good. "If they just covered better, Watt would get more sacks." He got manhandled by a Rookie Saturday but that doesn't matter. So Tomlin finds another way with the help of the local lackeys.
 
yeah, unfortunately the steelers locker room culture seems to be more enabling such behaviors in the last decade than it is "Fixing" it.

15-20 years ago, steelers culture was an asset, now? pretty much a liability and major cause of our lack of success..
How so ?

Seems the ravens and Texans culture also dumped DJ .

Frankly - “culture” is a silly thing people create as a narrative when a talented team wins .
And is blamed when losing happens .

Did the culture Cowher have fail with his losing seasons ?
Or - did the talent level improve?
 
Incorrect .
I’m using data and logic .
You guys aren’t
I said “mildly productive” and you found the need, I assume due to emotion, to correct me and say he’s “productive”.

Congrats you win. Hope you feel better.
 
I tell you what’s surly emotional to the average yinzer. Pickens, an underachieving head case, is probably the #4 player on the roster and the three players ahead of him are two vets aging out and the kicker.

This team is a mess.
 
Yep
It’s sop for local sports media
They hated a total effort guy like juju as well .

Should ask why TJ had zero tackles for a few games in a row ?

it was one person in the media who hated on JuJu for no reason other than to drive up his own engagement/ratings. JuJu was never going to be a #1 receiver, but he was a decent player who I thought contributed well to the team.
 
I tell you what’s surly emotional to the average yinzer. Pickens, an underachieving head case, is probably the #4 player on the roster and the three players ahead of him are two vets aging out and the kicker.

This team is a mess.

I’d take a couple of receivers as productive as Pickens for less than $2 mil a year , rather than the $12m for the second best receiver on the team .

you know what makes a coaches’ job easier ? Talent .
Not people who come up short in the game but plays nice with the media .
 
They won't go after TJ. He's been deemed a superstar talent just like the superstar coach. Everyone is willing to admit he's underperformed but there's always a reason. TJ gets a pass because the coverage isn't good. "If they just covered better, Watt would get more sacks." He got manhandled by a Rookie Saturday but that doesn't matter. So Tomlin finds another way with the help of the local lackeys.
TJ is getting all kinds of heat on the radio at least. not sure he's untouchable like you guys are claiming. many steeler fans asking that question and honestly, i'd bet more steeler fans would be open to trading him for draft picks over re-signing him...

im not necessarily down on him but would absolutely in a heartbeat, trade him for a first or second rd pick. not out or anger but just makes sense. and with a great career already, the steelers probably owe him a chance to play for a competitor. lets face it, we got his best years, let him go play somewhere for a team that has a chance
 
I’d take a couple of receivers as productive as Pickens for less than $2 mil a year , rather than the $12m for the second best receiver on the team .

you know what makes a coaches’ job easier ? Talent .
Not people who come up short in the game but plays nice with the media .
Steeler exit interviews with the media, they talked about being a fractured locker room. Do you know what fractures a locker room? A coach who treats players differently than other players. Tomlin always says he treats players differently, but fairly. What’s fair about a head case like Pickens being allowed to be chronically late for games and practices, while other players have to show up on time? do you want know how a five game losing streak happens to end the season, that could be part of the reason. I don’t think George makes Tomlin’s job easier. He contributes to the stress.
 
TJ is getting all kinds of heat on the radio at least. not sure he's untouchable like you guys are claiming. many steeler fans asking that question and honestly, i'd bet more steeler fans would be open to trading him for draft picks over re-signing him...

im not necessarily down on him but would absolutely in a heartbeat, trade him for a first or second rd pick. not out or anger but just makes sense. and with a great career already, the steelers probably owe him a chance to play for a competitor. lets face it, we got his best years, let him go play somewhere for a team that has a chance
Trade him.

Sadly an insider yesterday said that he anticipates the steeler signing him to an extension. I hate when organizations hang on to a player too long. I don’t care how productive he might be for a couple more years. To me it’s not worth it when you’re not a contender.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT