First, he is absolutely a good coach. But the fact that Pitt fans pine for the guy to be hired is absolutely a function of him having played here. Art Walker has won 3 state titles, but I don’t recall him ever being suggested as a candidate for a Pitt job. Is Narduzzi a moron and the admin incompetent for not hiring him also?
Second, just because the guy is a good coach doesn’t mean he is the best fit on this staff. I get the concern about Narduzzi’s penchant for hiring “his” guys. But that’s the way it tends to work. I also think he’s gone away from that on offense with Whipple, Marion and Beatty. On D I think that approach is merited, given that it is his D and they have done well. There is something to be said for hiring a coach who you have worked with and already understands what is expected of the position within your scheme.
As for connecting with the local kids, they seemed to do okay with the local kids in this class. I don’t think they lack for a local presence.